Product reviewRoofing & Exterior

Best Adhesive For Roof Shingles: Top Picks Compared for Your Repair

Updated 7 min read

Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Choosing the best adhesive for roof shingles depends on what you need to bond. Some products are made to attach replacement granules to a shingle surface, while others are labeled for roll roofing. Those uses are not interchangeable. Compare the product’s stated purpose with your repair, and follow its label and your roofing manufacturer’s guidance before applying anything.

Quick Comparison

ProductBest suited forKey detail
PERMAGLUE Regranulation AdhesiveBonding replacement granules to shingle surfacesApply by brush, roller, or sprayer; the listed coverage is 100 square feet per gallon
Rust-Oleum Adhesive Roofing RollShoppers looking specifically for a roll-roofing adhesiveListed as a black, one-gallon roofing adhesive
Gardner-Gibson Roll Roof AdhesiveRoll roofing work and repairsNo heating is needed, according to the product description

Our Picks: Best Adhesive For Roof Shingles reviews

PERMAGLUE: A Granule-Bonding Option for Shingle Surfaces

PERMAGLUE is designed to bond replacement roofing granules to shingle surfaces. That makes it a more specific choice than a general roofing adhesive: its stated purpose is regranulation, not simply attaching a loose shingle tab or sealing every type of roof repair.

The product description says it forms a film over non-porous or previously coated surfaces and can be applied with a brush, roller, or sprayer. It lists coverage of 100 square feet per gallon and calls for broadcasting shingle granules into the wet adhesive. The manufacturer also describes it as low-VOC and environmentally friendly.

This is the clearest match in this group if your task is replacing granules on a shingle roof. The product description also says to apply it before a shingle sealer or PERMAKOTE SHINGLE application as needed. Check the full directions to confirm that your surface and repair method are suitable.

A key limitation is that regranulation is a narrow use. If you need to secure a lifted shingle, repair a tear, or adhere roll roofing, this product’s stated purpose may not match your job. The listed coverage is also an estimate to plan around, not a substitute for the label’s application directions.

Pros:

  • Specifically designed to bond replacement granules to shingle surfaces
  • Can be applied by brush, roller, or sprayer
  • Lists coverage of 100 square feet per gallon
  • Described as low-VOC

Cons:

  • Its stated use is granule bonding, not every type of shingle repair
  • Requires broadcasting granules into the adhesive

Verdict: Choose PERMAGLUE when your main goal is regranulating a suitable shingle surface, not when you need an all-purpose shingle-tab adhesive.

Rust-Oleum Adhesive Roofing Roll: A Product to Check for Roll Roofing

The supplied product details identify this as a black, one-gallon Rust-Oleum adhesive for roofing roll. They do not provide application steps, compatible materials, coverage, or drying information, so it is important to verify those details on the product label or listing before choosing it.

Its name points to roll roofing rather than a dedicated adhesive for asphalt-shingle tabs or granule replacement. That distinction matters: a product intended for one roofing material should not be assumed to work with another. Compare the label with your roofing material and the repair you plan to make.

This option may be worth investigating if you specifically need an adhesive for roll roofing and can confirm that its directions fit your project. It is harder to recommend for shingle work because the available description does not establish that use. The supplied product data also lists it as unavailable, so check the listing for current status and details.

Pros:

  • Clearly identified as a roofing-roll adhesive
  • Listed in a one-gallon size
  • Black color is specified in the product name

Cons:

  • The supplied description does not explain compatible surfaces or application directions
  • Not identified as a shingle-tab or granule-bonding adhesive

Verdict: Consider this only if you need a roll-roofing adhesive and confirm that the label matches your materials; the available details are too limited to recommend it for standard shingle repairs.

Gardner-Gibson Roll Roof Adhesive: No-Heat Application for Roll Roofing

Gardner-Gibson 6150-9-34 is described as a roll roof adhesive for new construction or repairs. Its key stated convenience is that no heating is needed. The container size is 3.6 quarts, making it a smaller package than the one-gallon products in this comparison.

This product is a more clearly described choice than the Rust-Oleum option for roll-roofing work because the supplied details specify both its intended category and that it can be used for repairs or new construction. They do not, however, state its coverage, application tools, or compatibility with asphalt shingles. Do not assume it is suitable for shingle tabs or granule bonding without checking the label.

For someone working with roll roofing, the no-heat detail may help narrow the options. For a shingle repair, PERMAGLUE is more directly relevant only when the job is regranulation; neither product description here confirms a general-purpose adhesive for fastening loose asphalt shingles.

Pros:

  • Described for roll roofing repairs and new construction
  • No heating is needed, according to the product description
  • Smaller 3.6-quart container may suit a limited job

Cons:

  • Not identified as a granule-bonding or shingle-tab adhesive
  • The supplied details do not state coverage or application method

Verdict: Choose Gardner-Gibson for a roll-roofing project if its label fits your materials; look for a product specifically approved for your repair if you are working on asphalt-shingle tabs.

How to Choose an Adhesive for Roof Shingles

Match the adhesive to the repair

Start by identifying what needs to be bonded. Replacing loose granules, fastening a lifted shingle, patching a damaged area, and installing roll roofing are different tasks. The products here do not all claim the same purpose: PERMAGLUE is described for granule bonding, while the other two are identified as roll-roofing adhesives. Choose by the stated use, not just by the word “roofing” on the package.

Check material compatibility

Confirm that the adhesive is intended for your roof material and the surface condition. A product description that mentions roll roofing does not establish compatibility with asphalt shingles, and a granule-bonding product should not be treated as a general shingle fastener. Read the full label and follow any guidance from the roof-material manufacturer.

Look for clear application directions

Application details can affect whether a product is practical for your job. PERMAGLUE lists brush, roller, or sprayer application and instructs users to broadcast granules into the adhesive. Gardner-Gibson states that heating is not needed. The supplied Rust-Oleum details do not explain how to apply it, so verify the directions before buying.

Estimate the amount you need

Compare the listed coverage with the area you plan to treat, while allowing for the surface and application method. PERMAGLUE lists 100 square feet per gallon. The supplied details do not give coverage figures for the other two products, so consult their packaging or product information rather than guessing.

Consider the project size and package

Package size can help you avoid buying far more adhesive than the job requires, but the right amount depends on coverage and the repair area. The options here include one-gallon products and a 3.6-quart container. Check the stated coverage and storage directions to decide which size makes sense.

Plan for safe roof work

Roof work can be hazardous. Read the product label before application, use the safety precautions it specifies, and avoid working in conditions that make the roof unsafe. If the damage is extensive, the roof material is uncertain, or the repair is beyond your comfort level, consult a qualified roofing professional.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best adhesive for roof shingles?

It depends on the repair. Of these options, PERMAGLUE is the clearest match for bonding replacement granules to shingle surfaces. The other two products are described as roll-roofing adhesives, not general shingle-tab adhesives.

Can I use PERMAGLUE to secure a loose shingle?

The supplied description identifies PERMAGLUE as a granule-bonding product. It does not say that it is intended to secure loose shingle tabs, so check the label and use an adhesive specifically suited to that repair.

Are roll-roofing adhesive and shingle adhesive the same?

Not necessarily. The product descriptions distinguish roll-roofing adhesives from PERMAGLUE’s granule-bonding purpose. Confirm that a product is approved for your roof material and the exact task before applying it.

How do you apply PERMAGLUE?

The supplied description says it can be applied by brush, roller, or sprayer, with shingle granules broadcast into the adhesive. Follow the product label for complete preparation and application directions.

Does Gardner-Gibson Roll Roof Adhesive require heating?

No heating is needed, according to the supplied product description. Check the full label for other application steps and surface requirements.

How much PERMAGLUE should I buy?

The listed coverage is 100 square feet per gallon. Use that figure as a planning guide, then check the label for the coverage and application details that apply to your roof surface.

Final Recommendation

For bonding replacement granules to a shingle surface, PERMAGLUE is the most clearly matched option in this group. For roll roofing, Gardner-Gibson provides the more specific supplied details, including its no-heat application note. The Rust-Oleum product may also be worth checking for roll-roofing work, but its available description is limited. For any shingle repair beyond granule replacement, choose an adhesive whose label explicitly supports your material and repair method.

Rate this post
Spread the love

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top