An indoor turkey fryer can make holiday cooking easier without the setup and outdoor space needed for a propane fryer. The right choice depends on the size of turkey you plan to cook, how much counter space you have, and whether you want one appliance for frying, boiling, and steaming. Below, we compare five electric options, including models with clearly stated capacities and one older model whose listing provides few details.
Table of Contents
Quick Comparison
| Product | Stated capacity | Other uses | Standout detail |
|---|---|---|---|
| Masterbuilt 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Turkey Fryer | Up to a 20-pound turkey | Boiling and steaming | Drain valve and magnetic breakaway cord |
| Butterball Stainless Steel 14-Lb Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer | Up to a 14-pound turkey | Frying, boiling, and steaming | 1,650-watt heating element; listed as unavailable in the supplied product data |
| Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer | Up to a 14-pound turkey | Frying, boiling, and steaming | 1,650-watt heating element and viewing window |
| Masterbuilt Butterball XXL Digital Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer | Not stated in the supplied details | Not stated in the supplied details | XXL digital model; red finish |
| Masterbuilt 20010406 Electric Digital Turkey Fryer | Up to a 14-pound turkey | Frying, boiling, and steaming | 28-quart aluminum pot with adjustable temperature and timer |
Product availability and listing details can change. Check the product page and manual for current specifications before buying.
Our Picks: Best Indoor Turkey Deep Fryer reviews
1. Masterbuilt 3-in-1 XL Fryer: Best for a Larger Turkey
This Masterbuilt model is the largest-capacity option in this group with a stated turkey limit: it can fry a turkey weighing up to 20 pounds. Its 10.6-quart cooking pot also supports boiling and steaming, so it can handle other meals and gatherings throughout the year.
The design includes a cooking basket with a lifting hook, a drain valve, and a magnetic breakaway cord. The product description also says it uses less oil than a traditional deep fryer. These features may make handling and draining easier, though you still need to follow the fill limits and safety instructions in the manual.
The main trade-off is its size. A larger pot can be useful for a big bird, but it takes more room to use and store than a smaller-capacity fryer. It is a strong fit if turkey size is your top concern and you also want a fryer that can boil or steam.
Pros:
- Stated capacity for a turkey up to 20 pounds
- Can fry, boil, or steam
- Drain valve and basket with lifting hook
- Magnetic breakaway cord
Cons:
- Larger capacity may require more storage space
- Check the manual for operating and cleaning instructions before use
Verdict: Choose this model if you want the highest stated turkey capacity among these picks and value having boiling and steaming functions too.
2. Butterball 14-Lb Indoor Fryer: A Multi-Use Option With a Stock Caveat
This Butterball-branded electric model is described as a fryer, steamer, and boiler with room for a turkey up to 14 pounds. The supplied specifications list a 1,650-watt heating element and a magnetic breakaway cord. It is also described as suitable for frying chicken wings or preparing a seafood boil.
There is a detail worth checking before you buy: the title calls the fryer stainless steel, while the supplied description mentions a porcelain-coated inner pot. Confirm the current product details if the materials matter to you. The product data also lists this item as unavailable, so its status may need to be checked on the retailer’s page.
At its stated capacity, this is better suited to smaller birds than the 20-pound Masterbuilt model above. Its three cooking functions make it more versatile than a fryer meant only for turkey, but the listing’s availability and construction details are reasons to compare carefully.
Pros:
- Fry, boil, or steam with one appliance
- Stated capacity for a turkey up to 14 pounds
- 1,650-watt heating element
- Magnetic breakaway cord and drain valve
Cons:
- Listed as unavailable in the supplied product data
- Product title and description differ on material details
Verdict: Consider it if the current listing confirms the availability and construction you want; otherwise, the similar available Butterball-style option below is easier to assess from the supplied details.
3. Masterbuilt Butterball Fryer: Best for Monitoring While Cooking
This indoor electric fryer is listed with a 14-pound turkey capacity and three cooking modes: frying, boiling, and steaming. It has a 1,650-watt heating element, a built-in drain valve, and dishwasher-safe components according to the supplied description.
A folding window in the lid lets you monitor the cooking without lifting it. The product description also lists a porcelain-coated inner pot and basket, a drain clip, and a magnetic breakaway cord. Together, these features make it a practical choice for cooks who want a mid-size fryer with a few helpful handling and cleanup details.
It does not have the stated turkey capacity of the 3-in-1 XL model, and the supplied information does not give a pot volume. If you are choosing between this and the 14-pound Butterball option above, compare the current listings: their descriptions are very similar, but this one includes a viewing window and is listed as available in the supplied data.
Pros:
- Stated capacity for a turkey up to 14 pounds
- Frying, boiling, and steaming functions
- Folding viewing window and drain valve
- Magnetic breakaway cord
Cons:
- Smaller stated turkey limit than the 20-pound option
- Does not list the pot volume in the supplied details
Verdict: This is a sensible pick if a 14-pound limit is enough and you want a viewing window plus several cooking modes.
4. Masterbuilt Butterball XXL Digital Fryer: A Model to Verify Before Choosing
The supplied product title identifies this as a Masterbuilt Butterball XXL Digital indoor electric turkey fryer, with a red finish. The listing calls it the largest-capacity and newest model, but provides no description with a specific turkey limit, pot size, cooking modes, or included accessories.
That lack of detail makes it harder to compare with the other options here. The “XXL” name may catch your eye, but it is not a substitute for a stated capacity. Before buying, check the current listing and product manual for the turkey size it can hold, its controls, dimensions, and cleaning instructions.
This option could suit someone specifically looking for this named digital model, but shoppers who want clear capacity information may find the 20-pound or 14-pound choices easier to evaluate. Its supplied data does list it as available.
Pros:
- Identified as an indoor electric turkey fryer
- Digital model with a red finish, according to the title
- Listed as available in the supplied product data
Cons:
- No capacity or pot-size details supplied
- Cooking functions and accessories are not described
Verdict: Choose this only after confirming its capacity and features on the current product page; the supplied details are too limited for a confident size comparison.
5. Masterbuilt 20010406 Digital Fryer: Best for a 14-Pound Bird and Timer Controls
This Masterbuilt electric model has a 28-quart aluminum pot and is listed for turkeys up to 14 pounds. It can also boil and steam, making it useful for more than a holiday bird. An adjustable temperature control and timer give you settings to manage during cooking.
The product data describes a glass lid, powder-coated outer shell, and detachable 24-inch cord. It is listed as safe for countertop use, but you should still follow the manual’s placement, ventilation, and operating instructions. The listed dimensions are 19 by 20 by 17 inches, so measure your counter and storage area before you commit.
Compared with the 14-pound Butterball-style models, this one clearly states its pot volume and control features. Its aluminum pot and hand-wash cleaning instructions may be a drawback if you prefer dishwasher-safe parts. It is a good fit if you want a defined 14-pound capacity and adjustable temperature and timer controls.
Pros:
- 28-quart pot with a stated 14-pound turkey capacity
- Can fry, boil, and steam
- Adjustable temperature control and timer
- Includes a glass lid and detachable cord
Cons:
- Hand-wash cleaning is specified
- Listed dimensions may take up substantial counter or storage space
Verdict: Pick this model if you want a clearly specified 14-pound capacity, adjustable controls, and a 28-quart pot, and do not mind hand washing.
How to Choose an Indoor Turkey Deep Fryer
Match the fryer’s capacity to your turkey
Start with the turkey size you expect to cook. The models here list limits from 14 to 20 pounds, while the XXL digital model does not include a capacity in the supplied details. Do not assume a fryer can hold a bird based on its name or appearance; check the stated limit and follow the manual’s fill and loading instructions.
Check the pot size and available space
A large pot can be useful for a bigger bird or other batch cooking, but the appliance also needs room on your counter and in storage. One model lists dimensions of 19 by 20 by 17 inches, while several others do not provide dimensions in the supplied information. Measure your space and check the full product specifications before ordering.
Decide whether you want more than frying
Several options can also boil and steam. Those functions may make the appliance more useful for seafood boils, chicken, or vegetables, but only choose them if you expect to use them. Compare the specific cooking modes on the listing rather than assuming every indoor turkey fryer has the same functions.
Look at temperature and timer controls
Controls can affect how much attention you need to give a cooking task. The Masterbuilt 20010406 lists adjustable temperature control and a timer. The supplied details for other models do not always state what controls they include, so verify those features if they matter to you.
Consider draining and cleanup
Oil handling is an important part of using a fryer. A built-in drain valve can help direct liquid out of the pot, while dishwasher-safe components may simplify cleanup where specified. Check which parts are dishwasher-safe and whether the manual calls for hand washing. Never move or drain hot oil unless the appliance’s instructions specifically explain how to do so safely.
Review the safety features and instructions
Some models list a magnetic breakaway cord, which is designed to separate if the cord is pulled. This feature does not replace careful placement or safe operation. Use the fryer on a stable surface, keep it away from edges and children, and follow the maker’s instructions for oil level, setup, cooking, and draining. Make sure the turkey is prepared as the manual requires before it goes into hot oil.
Confirm the current listing details
Product names and descriptions can leave out important information, as with the XXL digital model’s unspecified capacity. The Butterball 14-pound listing also has a difference between its title and the supplied description about materials. Check the current product page for the exact model, materials, included parts, availability, and manual before buying.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you fry a turkey indoors with these appliances?
These are listed as indoor electric turkey fryers. Use them only as directed by the manufacturer, on a stable surface, and with the required clearance and setup. Read the manual before adding oil or cooking.
Which option has the largest stated turkey capacity?
The Masterbuilt 3-in-1 XL fryer is listed for a turkey up to 20 pounds. The other models with stated limits in the supplied details are listed for up to 14 pounds.
Can an indoor turkey fryer also boil or steam food?
Several models in this comparison are described as supporting boiling and steaming as well as frying. The supplied details for the XXL digital model do not specify its cooking modes, so check its current listing.
What size turkey should I buy?
Choose a turkey that stays within the fryer’s stated capacity, and follow the manufacturer’s instructions for preparing and loading it. A model’s maximum capacity is not a reason to exceed its fill line or other operating limits.
Are the fryer parts dishwasher-safe?
Some supplied product descriptions identify dishwasher-safe components, while the Masterbuilt 20010406 description says hand wash. Check the instructions for the exact model and each part before cleaning.
What should I do if the product page does not list the capacity?
Do not estimate capacity from words such as “XXL.” Check the current listing or manual for a maximum turkey size and pot dimensions. If those details are not available, consider a model with a clearly stated capacity.
Final Recommendation
For the largest stated turkey limit, the Masterbuilt 3-in-1 XL is the clearest choice, with a capacity of up to 20 pounds and added boiling and steaming functions. If a 14-pound bird is enough, the Masterbuilt Butterball model with a viewing window or the Masterbuilt 20010406 with its listed 28-quart pot and adjustable controls may be a better fit. Compare the current product details and follow the manual closely, especially when handling hot oil.