A brass floor drain cover can refresh a bathroom while helping keep hair and debris out of the drain, but the right replacement depends on more than its finish. You’ll need to match the cover’s outside diameter, attachment style, and—if it uses screws—the distance between the screw holes. These three options are designed for shower drains, and their materials and fit requirements differ, so check your existing drain before you choose.
Table of Contents
Quick Comparison
| Product | Material and finish | Fit and attachment | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Artiwell 4-Inch Screw-In Shower Strainer | Stainless steel stated in description; brushed gold finish | 4-inch outside diameter; screw-in; 3-3/8-inch hole spacing | Replacing a compatible screw-in cover |
| LXLOTUS 4¼-Inch Snap-In Shower Drain Cover | Solid brass; brushed gold finish | 4¼-inch outside diameter; snap-in | A brass cover for a compatible snap-in drain |
| Westbrass Shower Strainer Set | Solid brass; polished brass finish | Cover and crown ring; 2-13/16-inch screw spacing | Replacing a compatible 4T-style drain set |
Our Picks: Best Brass Floor Drain Cover reviews
Artiwell 4-Inch Screw-In Shower Strainer: A Brushed-Gold Replacement with Included Screws
The Artiwell is a screw-in shower strainer cover with a 4-inch outside diameter. Its brushed-gold finish can coordinate with gold-toned bathroom fixtures, and the package includes two machine screws and two self-tapping screws. Having both screw types gives you options for installation, but the cover still needs to match your drain’s size and hole spacing.
There’s an important material detail to check before buying: while the product title calls the cover solid brass, the supplied description says it is made of stainless steel with a plated and painted coating. If you specifically want a solid-brass cover, confirm the material on the current product listing before ordering. The listed dimensions—3-3/8 inches between screw-hole centers and 4 inches across—are the key fit checks.
This design is intended to catch hair and other debris before it enters the drain. Compared with the LXLOTUS, it attaches with screws rather than snapping into place. Its dimensions also differ from the Westbrass set, so the three products are not interchangeable based on appearance alone.
Pros:
- Includes both machine screws and self-tapping screws
- Brushed-gold finish offers a warm alternative to basic metal finishes
- Listed dimensions make it possible to check fit before purchase
- Designed to help catch hair and debris at the drain opening
Cons:
- The product title and description give conflicting material information
- Fits only drains with compatible screw-hole spacing and dimensions
Verdict: Choose the Artiwell if your existing cover is a 4-inch screw-in style with 3-3/8-inch hole spacing, but verify the material first if solid brass is a must-have.
LXLOTUS 4¼-Inch Snap-In Cover: Solid Brass with a Brushed-Gold Finish
The LXLOTUS is the clearest match here for shoppers seeking a solid-brass cover with a brushed-gold appearance. It has a stated outside diameter of 4¼ inches and a snap-in design, so it does not use the visible screw attachment found on the Artiwell and Westbrass options.
Its brass construction and gold finish suit a bathroom where the drain cover is part of the overall fixture look. The strainer is also intended to help keep hair and debris from entering the pipes. For a secure fit, measure the drain opening and confirm that it accepts this style of snap-in cover; the stated diameter alone cannot confirm compatibility with every drain.
Compared with the Westbrass set, the LXLOTUS is a simpler, single-cover replacement rather than a cover-and-crown-ring set with specified screw spacing. Compared with the Artiwell, it is described as solid brass, but it requires a compatible snap-in drain instead of a screw-in fitting.
Pros:
- Solid brass construction is stated in the product description
- Brushed-gold finish can complement gold-toned bathroom fixtures
- Snap-in attachment avoids a screw-based installation
- Designed to help block hair and debris from entering the drain
Cons:
- Only suitable for a compatible snap-in drain
- The description does not provide screw-hole measurements or a broader fit range
Verdict: Pick the LXLOTUS if you want a solid-brass, brushed-gold cover and have confirmed that your shower drain accepts a 4¼-inch snap-in style.
Westbrass Shower Strainer Set: A Polished-Brass Cover and Crown Ring
The Westbrass is a set rather than just a replacement grate. It includes a 3½-inch outside-diameter crown ring and a 3-5/16-inch outside-diameter drain cover, both described as solid brass. The polished-brass finish gives it a brighter look than the brushed-gold options in this comparison.
Fit is especially important with this set. It is designed for Plumbing Products and similar 4T-style drains, with screw holes spaced 2-13/16 inches center-to-center. Two matching flat-head screws are included. Measure the existing drain and compare those dimensions before ordering; the listed fit is specific, not a promise that it works with every shower drain.
The Westbrass may suit you if your current drain has a separate crown ring and cover, or if you want to replace both pieces together. Unlike the LXLOTUS snap-in cover, it uses screws. Its dimensions also differ from the Artiwell, making it a distinct fit choice despite the similar general purpose.
Pros:
- Solid brass construction is stated for the set
- Includes both a cover and a crown ring
- Matching screws are included
- Specific screw spacing and compatible drain style are provided
Cons:
- Designed for compatible 4T-style drains, not every drain body
- Polished brass may not match brushed-gold or other matte fixtures
Verdict: Choose the Westbrass set if your drain is a compatible 4T-style model and you want a solid-brass cover and crown ring in a polished finish.
How to Choose a Brass Floor Drain Cover
Measure the Existing Cover and Drain
Start by measuring the outside diameter of the cover and, if it uses screws, the distance between the centers of the screw holes. The measurements in these listings are not the same: the Artiwell is 4 inches across with 3-3/8-inch hole spacing, while the Westbrass cover is 3-5/16 inches across with 2-13/16-inch screw spacing. The LXLOTUS is 4¼ inches across and uses a snap-in attachment. A small mismatch can prevent a cover from sitting securely.
Match the Attachment Style
Check whether your current cover screws into the drain, snaps into place, or sits with a separate ring. A screw-in cover needs compatible holes and screws. A snap-in cover needs a drain opening made to hold that style. The Westbrass set includes a cover and crown ring, while the other two options are described as replacement covers. Don’t assume that one attachment type can replace another.
Confirm the Material, Not Just the Finish
A gold or brass-colored finish does not by itself mean a product is made of brass. The LXLOTUS and Westbrass descriptions specify solid brass. The Artiwell product title says solid brass, but its description identifies stainless steel with a plated and painted coating. If the underlying material matters to you, resolve that discrepancy using the current listing information before buying.
Choose a Finish That Fits Your Bathroom
Brushed gold tends to have a softer, less reflective appearance than polished brass. The Artiwell and LXLOTUS are listed with gold-toned finishes, while the Westbrass has a polished-brass finish. Color can vary between products and manufacturers, so an exact match with an existing faucet or shower fixture is not guaranteed.
Consider What Comes in the Package
Look at whether you need only a cover or a more complete replacement set. The Artiwell includes two types of screws, and the Westbrass includes matching screws along with its cover and crown ring. The LXLOTUS is described as a snap-in replacement cover. Check the package details against the parts you plan to replace.
Think About Debris and Drain Care
These covers are intended to help catch hair and debris, but the shape and opening pattern affect how debris collects and how easily you can clean around the drain. Regularly clear collected material from the cover so it does not build up. A strainer cover can help keep debris out of the pipe, but it does not remove the need for routine cleaning.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are these covers suitable for every floor drain?
No. The listed products are intended for compatible shower drains, and each has a specific size or attachment style. Check your drain’s diameter, attachment method, and screw spacing before ordering.
Which option is explicitly described as solid brass?
The LXLOTUS and Westbrass descriptions specify solid brass. The Artiwell title says solid brass, but its product description says stainless steel with a plated and painted coating, so verify that listing before choosing it for its material.
How do I measure screw-hole spacing?
Measure from the center of one screw hole to the center of the other. Compare that measurement with the product specifications. For the Artiwell, the stated spacing is 3-3/8 inches; for the Westbrass, it is 2-13/16 inches.
Can I use a snap-in cover on a drain with screws?
Not necessarily. Snap-in and screw-in covers attach differently. Buy a snap-in model only if your drain is designed to hold one; otherwise, choose a compatible screw-in cover.
Does a brass-colored finish mean the cover is solid brass?
No. A brass or gold appearance describes the finish, not always the base material. Check the product’s material description, especially when that distinction matters to your purchase.
Will the finish match my existing bathroom fixtures?
Not always. Finishes can look different across brands and product lines. The Artiwell description notes that its brushed-gold finish may have slight color variation when paired with fixtures from other manufacturers.
Final Recommendation
For a solid-brass cover with a brushed-gold finish, the LXLOTUS is the most direct match in this selection—provided your drain accepts a 4¼-inch snap-in cover. If you have a compatible 4T-style drain and want a cover plus crown ring, consider the Westbrass set. The Artiwell is a possible screw-in replacement when its dimensions match your drain, but confirm its material because the title and description conflict. In every case, fit should come first: measure before you buy.
