Product reviewKitchen & Appliances

Best Catalytic Wood Burning Stove: Top Picks and How to Choose

Updated 10 min read

Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

If you’re searching for the best catalytic wood burning stove, the key distinction is whether a stove actually has a catalytic combustor. Of these five options, only the Buck Stove Model 91 is identified as catalytic. The other four use secondary combustion without a catalyst, so they may be worth comparing if you’re open to a non-catalytic stove—but they are not direct substitutes for a catalytic model.

Use the comparison below to narrow your choices by heating area, firebox capacity, and stove type. Before buying, confirm that the stove and chimney system suit your home and meet local installation requirements.

StoveTypeKey detailsBest suited for
Buck Stove Model 91CatalyticUp to 62,745 BTUs; freestanding or insert setupShoppers who specifically want a catalytic stove
US Stove US1100E-LNon-catalytic, secondary combustionUp to 1,200 sq. ft.; accepts logs up to 18 inchesSmaller spaces and shoppers who want leg or pedestal options
Comfort Glow Cast Iron Wood StoveEPA-certified; catalyst not specifiedHeats up to 900 sq. ft.; accepts logs up to 22 inchesCompact spaces, cabins, and cooking on the stove top
Ashley Hearth AW2020-PNon-catalytic, secondary combustionUp to 2,000 sq. ft.; accepts logs up to 21 inchesLarger areas that need a higher-output stove
Comfort Glow CGWS1500Non-catalytic, secondary combustionHeats up to 1,200 sq. ft.; accepts logs up to 18 inchesMedium-sized spaces and buyers who prefer a pedestal design

Our Picks: Best Catalytic Wood Burning Stove reviews

1. Buck Stove Model 91: The Catalytic Pick

The Buck Stove Model 91 is the only stove in this lineup explicitly identified as catalytic. Its listed output reaches 62,745 BTUs, and the product description says it can heat a single room or a large-sized house. Actual results will depend on your home’s layout, insulation, climate, and installation.

The traditional design can be configured as a freestanding stove or an insert, and the description lists steel legs and a heat-activated blower. Door and window color options include black, pewter, and gold. Those choices add flexibility, but make sure the specific configuration you select matches your installation plan.

A catalytic stove is the clearest fit here if you’re set on a catalyst-based design. The tradeoff is that catalytic stoves require attention to the combustor and the manufacturer’s care instructions. The supplied product details do not state its firebox size or maximum log length, so check the full specifications before deciding whether it fits your usual wood supply.

Pros:

  • The only model in this group explicitly described as catalytic
  • Freestanding or insert installation options
  • Listed output of up to 62,745 BTUs
  • Heat-activated blower and several finish options

Cons:

  • Firebox capacity and maximum log length are not stated in the supplied details
  • A catalytic combustor adds care requirements compared with a basic stove design

Verdict: Choose the Buck Stove Model 91 if a catalytic stove is your priority and its installation options and full specifications suit your home.

2. US Stove US1100E-L: A Compact Non-Catalytic Option

The US Stove US1100E-L is a non-catalytic wood stove with a secondary combustion system. It is listed at up to 68,000 BTUs for spaces up to 1,200 square feet. That makes it a smaller-capacity alternative to the Buck and Ashley models, but it does not have the catalytic setup called for in this article’s target category.

Its 1.3-cubic-foot firebox accepts logs up to 18 inches long. The stove comes with both adjustable legs and a pedestal base, so you can choose between two looks. A firebrick-lined interior, cast iron door, air-washed ceramic glass, and removable ash pan round out the listed features.

This model may suit a smaller home or area where you want a choice of base style. It is designed for a standard 6-inch chimney connector and chimney system, which are not included. The listing also specifies freight delivery and requires a valid phone number or email for scheduling, so plan for the delivery process as well as installation.

Pros:

  • Listed heating coverage of up to 1,200 square feet
  • Accepts logs up to 18 inches
  • Includes both leg and pedestal options
  • Removable ash pan and firebrick-lined interior

Cons:

  • Uses secondary combustion, not a catalytic combustor
  • Chimney system is not included, and delivery requires coordination

Verdict: Consider the US1100E-L if you want a non-catalytic stove for a smaller area and value its two base options.

3. Comfort Glow Cast Iron Stove: Compact Heat with a Cooktop

This Comfort Glow stove is a cast iron indoor heater listed for spaces up to 900 square feet. It is EPA certified, but the supplied description does not identify it as catalytic. Treat it as a compact alternative rather than a confirmed catalytic model.

The firebox is described as accepting logs up to 22 inches, a notable length for a stove in this size range. Its flat cooking surface can be used to boil, fry, or warm food, which may be useful in a cabin or off-grid setting. The spring handle is designed to stay cooler during use, and the stove has a standard 6-inch flue collar.

Its listed heating area is the smallest of the five, making it a more natural candidate for a compact living space than a large open home. The cooking surface is a practical extra, but it should not be the main reason to choose the stove unless the heating capacity and installation requirements also work for you.

Pros:

  • Listed coverage of up to 900 square feet
  • Accepts logs up to 22 inches
  • Integrated cooking surface
  • Cast iron construction and EPA certification

Cons:

  • Catalytic design is not specified in the supplied information
  • Listed heating area is lower than the other options in this comparison

Verdict: Pick this Comfort Glow model if you need a compact heater with a cooktop and do not require a confirmed catalytic system.

4. Ashley Hearth AW2020-P: Higher Output for Larger Areas

The Ashley Hearth AW2020-P is a non-catalytic stove with secondary combustion. Its listed output is up to 89,000 BTUs, with coverage of up to 2,000 square feet. Among the non-catalytic choices here, it has the highest stated heating capacity.

The 1.6-cubic-foot firebox accepts logs up to 21 inches. Like the US Stove model, it includes adjustable legs and a pedestal, plus a firebrick-lined interior, cast iron door, air-washed glass, and removable ash pan. It does not require electricity to operate, though the optional circulator blower does require power and is sold separately.

This stove is aimed at a larger area than the other non-catalytic models in the comparison. Its higher output is not automatically an advantage in every home: consider your room size and layout, and ask an installer whether the stove can be operated comfortably without overheating your space. Freight delivery and a separate chimney system are also part of the planning.

Pros:

  • Listed coverage of up to 2,000 square feet
  • Up to 89,000 BTUs of output
  • Accepts logs up to 21 inches
  • Operates without electricity; blower is optional

Cons:

  • Uses secondary combustion rather than a catalytic combustor
  • Optional blower and chimney system are not included

Verdict: The AW2020-P is a strong non-catalytic candidate for a larger space, but it is not the right match if you specifically need a catalytic stove.

5. Comfort Glow CGWS1500: Pedestal Style for Mid-Sized Spaces

The Comfort Glow CGWS1500 is a plate-steel stove with a cast iron door and pedestal base. It is listed to heat up to 1,200 square feet and accept logs up to 18 inches. Its clean-burn technology uses secondary combustion, so this model is non-catalytic.

The firebrick-lined firebox is designed to support heat retention, while the large viewing window gives you a view of the fire. The stove is listed as approved for mobile and modular homes in the US, and it can use an optional blower sold separately. Check the exact installation requirements for your home before buying.

Compared with the US Stove US1100E-L, this model has a fixed pedestal look rather than the choice of legs or pedestal. It has the same stated heating area and log length, so the decision between them may come down to appearance and the details of each installation. Neither is a catalytic stove.

Pros:

  • Listed heating coverage of up to 1,200 square feet
  • Accepts logs up to 18 inches
  • Pedestal design and large viewing window
  • Optional blower available

Cons:

  • Secondary combustion system is not catalytic
  • Blower is sold separately

Verdict: Choose the CGWS1500 if its pedestal design and stated heating area suit your space, and a non-catalytic stove meets your needs.

How to Choose a Catalytic Wood Burning Stove

Confirm that the stove is truly catalytic

A catalytic stove uses a combustor to help burn smoke and other gases from the fire. A non-catalytic stove may also be designed for cleaner combustion, but it uses a different system. Check the product specifications and manual for an explicit mention of a catalytic combustor; terms such as “secondary combustion” or “clean burn” do not, by themselves, confirm a catalytic design.

Match the heating area to your home

Use the listed square-foot coverage as a starting point, not a guarantee. Open layouts, ceiling height, insulation, local climate, and how the home is divided can all affect how heat moves. A stove that is too powerful for its location may be difficult to run comfortably, while an undersized model may not meet your heating needs.

Check firebox size and log length

Firebox capacity and maximum log length affect the size of wood you can load and how the stove fits your routine. Compare the stove’s stated limits with the wood you can obtain and handle. The supplied details list log lengths for four models, but not for the Buck Stove Model 91, so confirm that information with the manufacturer or seller before purchasing.

Plan for the full installation

A stove is only one part of a safe wood-heating system. Check the required chimney, connector size, clearances, floor protection, and fresh-air requirements for your home and the specific model. Use a qualified installer and follow local codes and the stove’s manual. Several stoves in this comparison do not include their chimney system.

Consider electricity and accessories

Some stoves can operate without power, while blowers may need electricity to move heat around the room. Decide whether a blower matters for your layout or whether you want the stove to provide heat during a power outage. Check whether an accessory is included or sold separately; the Ashley blower, for example, is listed as optional.

Understand catalytic-stove care

A catalytic combustor needs proper use and routine care. Before choosing a catalytic model, read its operating and maintenance instructions, including how to inspect and clean the combustor and when it may need replacement. Do not assume that care requirements are the same for every stove.

Review delivery and warranty details

Large stoves may arrive by freight and require delivery scheduling, a suitable drop-off location, and help moving the unit. Check those details before ordering. The Buck Stove description lists a one-year replacement warranty and a five-year limited parts warranty, with manufacturer registration and installation compliance requirements; confirm the complete terms before purchase.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which stove in this comparison is catalytic?

The Buck Stove Model 91 is the only one explicitly described as catalytic in the supplied product information. The US Stove US1100E-L, Ashley Hearth AW2020-P, and Comfort Glow CGWS1500 are described as using secondary combustion without a catalyst. The other Comfort Glow listing does not specify a catalytic system.

Is secondary combustion the same as catalytic combustion?

No. Both designs aim to support more complete combustion, but a catalytic stove uses a combustor, while the listed secondary-combustion models do not. Check the manufacturer’s specifications if the presence of a catalyst is important to you.

Which option has the largest stated heating area?

The Ashley Hearth AW2020-P has the largest stated coverage in this group, at up to 2,000 square feet. That figure is a guide, not a promise for every home; layout, insulation, and installation affect real-world performance.

Which models include a blower?

The Buck Stove Model 91 description lists a heat-activated blower. The Ashley Hearth and Comfort Glow CGWS1500 list optional blowers sold separately. The US Stove and cast iron Comfort Glow descriptions do not list a blower.

Do these stoves include a chimney?

The US Stove US1100E-L is described as using a standard 6-inch chimney connector and chimney system, which are not included. The Ashley Hearth AW2020-P also lists its chimney connector and system as not included. Confirm all venting parts and installation needs for any model before buying.

Can a wood stove be used in a mobile home?

Some products in this comparison include mobile-home approval details, but the requirements vary by model and location. The US Stove listing specifies a fresh-air intake kit for mobile-home use in the US and Canada, while the Comfort Glow CGWS1500 is listed as approved for mobile and modular homes in the US. Verify the exact requirements in the product manual and local codes.

What should I prioritize if I want a catalytic model?

Start by confirming that the stove includes a catalytic combustor, then compare its heating capacity, firebox and log limits, installation needs, and maintenance instructions. In this lineup, the Buck Stove Model 91 is the explicit catalytic choice, but you should verify its full specifications before ordering.

Final Recommendation

For shoppers who specifically want a catalytic wood stove, the Buck Stove Model 91 is the clear match among these five options because it is the only one explicitly identified as catalytic. Its freestanding-or-insert flexibility and listed output are useful advantages, but check the complete firebox, log-size, and installation details first. If you are open to non-catalytic designs, the Ashley Hearth AW2020-P is the largest-capacity alternative, while the US Stove and Comfort Glow models offer options for smaller spaces.

Rate this post
Spread the love

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top