Product reviewDoors, Windows & Floors

Best Double Door Mailbox Plastic

Updated 10 min read

Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

A plastic double-door mailbox gives you access from the street and from your property side, which can make collecting mail more convenient when the box sits beside a road or driveway. The options below range from a basic mailbox-and-post combo to larger-capacity Step2 models. Compare the access doors, included mounting parts, and interior size to find the right fit for your home.

MailboxAccess and capacitySetup notesBest for
Simplay3 Classic Mailbox & Post Mount Combo KitTwo magnetic access doors; large interiorFits over a 4×4 wood post; post not includedA traditional look with access from both sides
Plexon Classic Plastic Double Door Mailbox and Post KitMedium capacity; letters, magazines, small parcelsDouble-walled plastic; check listing details for included mounting partsShoppers seeking a compact classic-style box
Step2 MailMaster Plus with Post & Newspaper HolderFront and rear access; large interiorDesigned to slide over a 4×4 wood post; wood post not includedHomes that need newspaper storage and extra stability
Step2 MailMaster Streamline MailboxFront and rear access; fits letters, magazines, and small packagesPost cover and mounting hardware included; wood post not includedA streamlined design with rear access
Step2 MailMaster XL MailboxFront and rear access; extra-large USPS T4-sized interiorPost cover and mounting hardware included; wood post not includedHouseholds that want room for more mail and packages

Our Picks: Best Double Door Mailbox Plastic reviews

1. Simplay3 Classic Plastic Mailbox and Post Mount Combo Kit

The Simplay3 Classic combines a traditional-looking mailbox with a post cover and mounting hardware. Its two heavy-duty magnetic access doors let you retrieve mail from the front or rear, a useful setup if you want to collect mail without stepping into the road.

The double-wall plastic construction is designed for residential use and is easy to wipe clean. The large interior is described as suitable for small boxes, catalogs, and envelopes. The kit also includes a red mail flag and adhesive address numbers, so several practical details are covered out of the box.

Installation is made for a new or existing 4×4 wood post, but the wood post itself is not included. That is worth checking before you order, especially if you are replacing a mailbox and need to plan for the post separately. Compared with the Step2 XL, this is a more traditional, less capacity-focused choice.

Pros:

  • Two magnetic doors allow front or rear mail access
  • Large interior accommodates catalogs and small boxes
  • Includes mounting hardware, post cover, flag, and address numbers
  • Double-wall plastic is easy to wipe clean

Cons:

  • 4×4 wood post is not included
  • No extra-large capacity claim for larger parcels

Verdict: Choose the Simplay3 if you want a classic-style double-access mailbox with useful installation accessories, and already have or plan to buy a 4×4 post.

2. Plexon Classic Double Door Mailbox and Post Kit

The Plexon Classic is a black plastic mailbox with front and rear access and a medium-capacity interior. Its listed internal dimensions are 20.41 inches long, 6.11 inches high, and 7.25 inches wide. That space is intended for letters, magazines, and small parcels rather than bulky deliveries.

The mailbox uses double-walled plastic, and its finish is described as UV-resistant to help limit fading and sun damage. It is also listed as compatible with a range of Gibraltar and Architectural Mailboxes accessories. If you want to add compatible accessories later, confirm the specific fit before purchasing.

This option may suit you if you prefer a classic form and do not need the extra-large interior of the MailMaster XL. The product listing’s availability can vary, so check the current listing and confirm exactly what is included in the post kit before ordering. The supplied product details do not specify a wood-post exclusion or provide the same setup instructions as the other choices.

Pros:

  • Front and rear access in a classic-style design
  • Double-walled plastic construction
  • UV-resistant finish is designed to resist fading
  • Medium interior can hold letters, magazines, and small parcels

Cons:

  • Medium capacity is less suited to larger packages
  • Confirm current availability and included mounting parts on the listing

Verdict: Consider the Plexon if you want a medium-capacity plastic mailbox with a UV-resistant finish, but verify availability and kit contents before you buy.

3. Step2 MailMaster Plus with Newspaper Holder

The Step2 MailMaster Plus pairs front and rear mail access with a separate newspaper holder. Its large interior is designed for mail, large letters, magazines, and small packages. A magnetic closure helps keep the main door shut, while the red flag gives you a way to signal outgoing mail.

Double-walled plastic forms the main body, and the product description notes steel-plate reinforcement for added stability in blustery conditions. It is also described as weather-resistant for exposure to rain, sleet, snow, and sun. These features make it a practical fit for a mailbox location that sees changing weather, though they do not remove the need for a secure installation.

The assembly is designed to slide over a 4×4 wooden post. The product details list a post cover, mounting hardware, and address numbers among the included parts, but state that the wooden post is not included. Compared with the Streamline, the newspaper holder is the clearest reason to choose this model; otherwise, their access and general capacity are similar.

Pros:

  • Front and rear access with a magnetic main-door closure
  • Newspaper holder adds a dedicated place for newspapers
  • Large interior fits magazines and small packages
  • Steel-plate reinforcement is specified for added stability

Cons:

  • 4×4 wooden post is not included
  • Its listed size may take up more space than a compact mailbox

Verdict: Pick the MailMaster Plus if you want rear access, a large mail compartment, and a built-in newspaper holder in one setup.

4. Step2 MailMaster Streamline Mailbox and Post Cover

The MailMaster Streamline is a plastic mailbox with front and rear access, a magnetic door closure, and a mocha finish. Its interior is intended for letters, magazines, and small packages. A raised flag can signal outgoing mail, making this a straightforward option for everyday residential use.

Like the MailMaster Plus, it has double-walled plastic construction and steel-plate reinforcement for stability in blustery conditions. The product description also says it is designed to withstand rain, sleet, snow, and sun. The listed dimensions are 51 inches high, 23.25 inches wide, and 12.5 inches deep when assembled.

The package includes a post cover and mounting hardware, but not the 4×4 wood post needed for installation. This is a useful distinction when comparing it with mailbox-only products, since you still need to supply a post. The Streamline’s main trade-off against the Plus is that the Plus specifically adds a newspaper holder.

Pros:

  • Front and rear access with magnetic door closure
  • Includes a post cover and mounting hardware
  • Double-walled plastic construction with steel-plate reinforcement
  • Fits letters, magazines, and small packages

Cons:

  • 4×4 wood post is not included
  • No newspaper holder is listed

Verdict: Choose the Streamline if you want a weather-oriented, double-access mailbox with a post cover, but do not need the Plus model’s newspaper holder.

5. Step2 MailMaster XL Extra-Large Mailbox

The MailMaster XL is the capacity-focused choice in this group. Its interior is described as extra-large and USPS T4 sized, with room for multiple days of mail and packages. Front and rear access doors make it easier to collect mail from either side, while the flag can be raised to indicate outgoing mail.

The mailbox uses double-walled plastic and includes steel-plate reinforcement for added stability. Its magnetic closure is designed to keep the door shut, and the product description lists weather resistance for rain, sleet, snow, and sun. At 54 inches high, 16.25 inches wide, and 21.75 inches deep when assembled, it is a substantial unit, so check the available space at your curb before choosing it.

The package includes a post cover and mounting hardware, but the 4×4 wooden post is not included. Compared with the MailMaster Plus, the XL offers a specifically stated T4-sized interior rather than a newspaper holder. If your mail is usually limited to letters, that extra capacity may be more than you need.

Pros:

  • Extra-large USPS T4-sized interior for mail and packages
  • Front and rear access with magnetic closure
  • Includes a post cover and mounting hardware
  • Double-walled plastic with steel-plate reinforcement

Cons:

  • 4×4 wooden post is not included
  • Larger assembled size may not suit every curbside space

Verdict: The MailMaster XL is the best fit here if you regularly receive more than letters and want the largest stated capacity, provided you have room for its larger footprint.

How to Choose a Plastic Double Door Mailbox

Check that the access doors suit your location

Double-door mailboxes let you retrieve mail from the front and rear. This can be helpful when the box faces a road and you want to collect mail from the safer side. Before choosing a model, consider where the mailbox will sit and whether you can reach both doors without stepping into traffic or crossing an obstacle.

Match the capacity to the mail you receive

A medium-capacity box can work well for letters, magazines, and occasional small parcels. If you often receive packages or want room for several days of mail, compare the larger options. The Step2 MailMaster XL is specifically described as USPS T4 sized, while the other models are described more generally as large or medium capacity.

Confirm what the kit includes

Some models include a post cover, mounting hardware, address numbers, or a flag. Those parts do not always include the structural wood post. The Simplay3 and Step2 listings state that a 4×4 wood post is not included. Check the product details carefully so you can plan for any parts you still need.

Consider plastic construction and weather exposure

Plastic mailboxes are easy to wipe clean, and several options here use double-walled construction. The Step2 models also list steel-plate reinforcement and weather resistance. If your mailbox location gets strong wind or direct sun, pay attention to the model’s stated reinforcement and finish details, and install it securely according to its instructions.

Measure the installation space

Mailbox size affects both curb appeal and how much room the unit occupies. The Step2 models list assembled measurements, while the Plexon listing provides separate mailbox-only dimensions. Make sure you compare like with like, and account for the post and surrounding space before ordering.

Compare the extras you will actually use

A newspaper holder, outgoing-mail flag, address numbers, and post cover can add convenience, but not every buyer needs each feature. For example, the MailMaster Plus lists a newspaper holder, while the Streamline does not. Choose the accessories that fit your routine rather than paying attention to a feature you are unlikely to use.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does “double door” mean on a mailbox?

In these product listings, it means the mailbox has access from the front and rear. That arrangement can let you retrieve mail from the side of the box that is most convenient for your property.

Does a double-door mailbox include the post?

Not always. The Simplay3 and Step2 product details specify that a 4×4 wooden post is not included, even when a post cover and mounting hardware are supplied. Check the individual listing for the exact parts in the package.

Which option has the most stated capacity?

The Step2 MailMaster XL is described as having an extra-large, USPS T4-sized interior for mail and packages. The other choices are described as large or medium capacity without that specific size designation.

Can these mailboxes hold small packages?

The Simplay3, Plexon, and Step2 descriptions mention space for small boxes or small packages. Their capacity is not the same, so check the interior dimensions or size description if package storage is a priority.

Are plastic mailboxes weather-resistant?

The supplied details describe weather resistance for the Step2 MailMaster Plus, Streamline, and XL, including exposure to rain, sleet, snow, and sun. The Plexon listing specifies a UV-resistant finish, while the Simplay3 description emphasizes durable, easy-to-clean construction. These descriptions are not a guarantee against every weather condition.

Which model includes a newspaper holder?

The Step2 MailMaster Plus specifically lists a newspaper holder. The other products in this group do not list one in their supplied descriptions.

What should I verify before ordering?

Confirm the mailbox dimensions, access-door placement, included hardware, post requirements, and current product availability. If you are replacing an existing mailbox, also check that the new model will fit your current post or installation area.

Final Recommendation

For a traditional look and a kit with useful included accessories, the Simplay3 Classic is a strong choice if you can supply a 4×4 post. The Step2 MailMaster Plus is the better fit if you want a newspaper holder, while the MailMaster XL is the most suitable option for shoppers who prioritize extra interior room. Whichever model you choose, confirm the post requirements and available installation space before ordering.

Rate this post
Spread the love

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top