A cooler drain plug is a small part that can make a big difference: the wrong fit may leak, while the right replacement helps restore normal draining and closure. The best choice depends on your cooler’s brand, model, and drain style. These five options cover select RTIC, Coleman, Yeti, and Igloo coolers, but compatibility is not universal—check your cooler and original plug before ordering.
Table of Contents
Quick Comparison
| Product | Designed for | What stands out |
|---|---|---|
| MetVot Large and Small RTIC Drain Plugs | Select RTIC dual-drain models | Includes one large and one small plug |
| telehybrid Coleman Drain Plug Set | Select Coleman coolers using part R5214D607G | Includes plugs, covers, and gaskets |
| Omoojee Cooler Drain Plugs | Specified Yeti Tundra and select RTIC models | Two plugs; intended as the smaller RTIC plug |
| Together-life RTIC Large and Small Drain Plugs | Select RTIC 20QT, 45QT, and 65QT coolers | One large and one small plug |
| Bremiqaro Igloo Threaded Drain Plug Kit | Select Igloo 50–165 Qt coolers with threaded 24011-style plugs | Replacement assembly for a specific threaded drain style |
Our Picks: Best Drain Plugs For Coolers reviews
1. MetVot Large and Small Plugs for Select RTIC Coolers
This two-piece set is made for select RTIC hard coolers with a dual drain plug system. It includes one large plug and one small plug, which is useful if both plugs are missing or worn. The listing names RTIC 20QT, 45QT, 65QT, 110QT, and 145QT models.
The plugs use ABS plastic and silicone sealing gaskets. Their screw-in design is intended to let you drain water with the plug partly open, rather than taking it all the way out. That can be handy when you want to control drainage while keeping the plug close at hand.
Fit is the key limitation. The listing specifically excludes RTIC 22QT, 32QT, 52QT, and 72QT models, so don’t rely on brand alone. This is a practical option when you have a listed RTIC model with two drain holes and need both plug sizes; it is not a universal replacement.
Pros:
- Includes one large and one small plug
- Silicone gaskets are designed to help seal the drain holes
- Can drain while partially open
- Specifies compatible RTIC models and exclusions
Cons:
- Not compatible with several RTIC sizes, including 22QT, 32QT, 52QT, and 72QT
- Best suited to coolers with the specified dual-drain setup
Verdict: Choose this set if your RTIC model appears on the compatibility list and you need both plug sizes; verify the model before buying.
2. telehybrid Replacement Set for Select Coleman Coolers
This replacement set is designed for Coleman coolers that use drain plug part R5214D607G, with a stated one-inch shaft length. The package includes two plugs, two drain covers, and two gaskets, making it a useful option when you need more than the plug alone.
The listing provides a long list of Coleman model numbers and recommends checking the number on the bottom of your cooler before ordering. That extra step matters: a Coleman name or similar-looking drain does not confirm that this part will fit. The product description says installation requires no tools, which may make a like-for-like replacement straightforward.
Compared with the RTIC sets here, this one is aimed at a different brand and uses a specific replacement part number. It is the most sensible pick for a compatible Coleman cooler, but less useful if you cannot confirm the model or part number.
Pros:
- Designed to replace part R5214D607G
- Includes plugs, covers, and gaskets
- Lists many compatible Coleman model numbers
- Described as a no-tools installation
Cons:
- Compatibility depends on the cooler model and original drain style
- Not presented as a universal Coleman plug
Verdict: This is a sensible replacement kit if your Coleman cooler uses R5214D607G; confirm the model number before placing an order.
3. Omoojee Two-Pack for Specified Yeti and RTIC Models
Omoojee’s two-pack is described as compatible with several Yeti Tundra models and select RTIC coolers. The listing also names Roadie and Tank in its title, but its detailed compatibility information focuses on Tundra and RTIC. If you have a Roadie or Tank, confirm the required plug dimensions and fit before ordering rather than relying on the title alone.
For RTIC, the description says these are replacements for the smaller plug on post-2017 coolers with one large and one small drain hole. The listing identifies the part as a replacement for OEM number 23010000000 and advises checking dimensions. Its finger knob is designed for opening and closing, and the plug can be left partly open to drain.
This set may suit someone who needs a spare or a replacement for a compatible smaller drain plug. Its narrower RTIC role is important: it does not replace the large and small pair offered by the two RTIC kits above.
Pros:
- Two plugs included
- Designed to drain while partly open
- Identifies an OEM part number for comparison
- Specifies the smaller-plug role for certain RTIC coolers
Cons:
- RTIC fit is limited to the smaller plug, not a full large-and-small set
- Some model names in the title are not detailed in the compatibility description
Verdict: Consider this pack when you need the specified smaller plug for a compatible cooler, and check dimensions carefully for Roadie or Tank fit.
4. Together-life Large and Small Plugs for RTIC 20QT, 45QT, and 65QT
This kit includes one large and one small screw-in gasket plug for select RTIC coolers with a dual drain plug system. The listed fit covers RTIC 20QT, 45QT, and 65QT models, making the compatibility range narrower than the MetVot set.
The plugs are designed to let water drain when partly unscrewed, so you do not have to remove them completely. The gasketed screw-in design is intended to seal the drain when closed. As with any replacement plug, a proper match to the cooler’s drain openings is essential for that seal to work as intended.
This is a straightforward choice for someone with one of the three listed RTIC sizes who wants both plug sizes in one kit. It does not list RTIC 110QT or 145QT compatibility, so buyers with those models should consider a product whose fit information includes them.
Pros:
- Includes one large and one small plug
- Made for RTIC’s dual-drain system
- Partial opening allows water to drain without fully removing the plug
- Gasketed screw-in design
Cons:
- Lists only RTIC 20QT, 45QT, and 65QT models
- Does not specify compatibility with other RTIC sizes
Verdict: Pick this set if your cooler is a listed RTIC size and you need a matched large-and-small replacement pair.
5. Bremiqaro Threaded Replacement Kit for Select Igloo Coolers
This kit is designed to replace a threaded Igloo drain plug assembly in the 24011 style. It is listed for select 50–165 Qt Igloo coolers, but the capacity range alone does not guarantee a fit. The original drain must use the specified threaded style.
The product is intended to replace worn, damaged, or missing drain components and restore normal opening, closing, and draining. Its main advantage is that it is described as a complete replacement assembly rather than just a plug. The listing also notes that it is not for Igloo Triple-Snap drains.
Because Igloo uses more than one drain style, this kit is best for shoppers who can compare the original part with the 24011-style description. If your cooler has a snap-in drain, this is not the right choice even if its capacity falls within the listed range.
Pros:
- Designed for threaded 24011-style assemblies
- Listed for select Igloo coolers from 50 to 165 Qt
- Intended as a replacement assembly for routine cooler repair
- Described as straightforward to install
Cons:
- Not compatible with Triple-Snap drain plugs
- Cooler capacity by itself does not confirm fit
Verdict: Choose this kit only if your Igloo cooler has the threaded 24011-style drain; verify the original plug type first.
How to Choose a Cooler Drain Plug
Match the cooler brand and model
Start with the model number, not just the cooler brand or capacity. A replacement may fit one group of models but not another, even within the same brand. Check the label or model information on your cooler and compare it with the product’s compatibility list before buying.
Identify the drain style
Look at the plug already on your cooler, or the opening if the plug is missing. Check whether it is threaded, screw-in, or a different style such as a snap-in drain. The Igloo kit here, for example, is for a threaded 24011-style assembly and is not for Triple-Snap drains.
Check the number and size of plugs
Some coolers use a dual-drain setup with one large and one small plug. If you need to replace both, choose a set that includes both sizes. If only one plug is missing, confirm whether the replacement is meant for the large or small opening; the Omoojee listing, for instance, describes its RTIC plugs as replacements for the smaller plug.
Compare part numbers and dimensions
When available, match the replacement part number to the number on your old plug or cooler documentation. Also compare the shape and dimensions shown in the product information. This is especially useful when a listing names several models or when a title and detailed fit notes do not describe the same range clearly.
Consider the seal and how you drain
Gaskets are intended to help seal the drain opening, while some screw-in designs can be left partly open during draining. Think about which features your original plug has and whether you need a full assembly, a gasket, or just a replacement plug. A close match to the original design is generally the safer choice than assuming a similar-looking part will work.
Read exclusions as carefully as compatibility claims
Exclusions can prevent a costly mismatch. The MetVot set, for example, lists several RTIC sizes it does not fit, while the Igloo kit excludes Triple-Snap drains. Treat the listed fit and exclusions as a pair, and contact the seller if your exact model or plug style is unclear.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are cooler drain plugs universal?
No. Plugs vary by brand, model, size, and drain style. Check the exact compatibility information and compare the replacement with your existing plug before ordering.
How can I tell which drain plug fits my cooler?
Find your cooler’s model number and identify the original drain style. Then compare those details with the product’s model list, part number, and dimensions. If the fit information is unclear, ask the seller before buying.
Can I use a small RTIC plug in place of a large one?
No. The Omoojee listing describes its RTIC plugs as replacements for the smaller drain on specified dual-drain coolers. A small plug should not be treated as a replacement for the large opening.
Do screw-in drain plugs need to be removed to drain a cooler?
Some of the screw-in plugs in this roundup are designed to drain while partly open. Follow the instructions for the specific plug and avoid removing it completely unless that is needed for your cooler’s drain design.
Will an Igloo replacement plug fit every 50–165 Qt cooler?
No. The Bremiqaro kit is for select Igloo coolers using a threaded 24011-style assembly. The listed capacity range does not guarantee compatibility, and the kit is not for Triple-Snap drains.
Should I replace the gasket along with the plug?
If the replacement set includes a gasket, use the components as directed. If you are reusing an existing plug, check its gasket for damage or wear; a poor seal can affect how well the drain closes.
Final Recommendation
For select RTIC dual-drain coolers, start with the plug set that matches your exact size: MetVot lists more RTIC models, while Together-life focuses on the 20QT, 45QT, and 65QT. For Coleman, match the cooler to part R5214D607G. Choose Omoojee when you need the specified smaller plug for a compatible model, and consider Bremiqaro only for an Igloo cooler with the threaded 24011-style drain. The best fit is the one that matches your original plug and cooler model—not simply the one with the broadest compatibility claim.
