Product reviewRoofing & Exterior

Best Felt Paper For Roofing: #15 vs #30 Compared and Ranked

Updated 9 min read

Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Choosing the best felt paper for roofing starts with matching the underlayment grade to your roof design, shingle instructions, and local building requirements. The options below include #15 felt for lighter-duty applications and #30 felt for projects that call for a thicker underlayment. Compare the product labels carefully: roll size, grade, and material details can vary, and some listings provide more information than others.

Quick Comparison

ProductGradeNotable detailAvailability shown
GAP Roofing 15 lb. Black Roofing Felt#15Black roofing feltAvailable
TARCO STD15 36×144 #15 Asphalt Felt#15Asphalt felt; US-made listingAvailable
ORGILL 30RF Standard Roofing Felt#30Described as twice the thickness of 15RFAvailable
Tarco Std30 36×72 #30 Asphalt Felt#30Asphalt felt rollUnavailable in supplied listing
GAP Roofing Black 216 sq. ft. #30 Felt#30216-square-foot roll listingUnavailable in supplied listing

Our Picks: Best Felt Paper For Roofing reviews

GAP Roofing 15 lb. Black Roofing Felt: A straightforward #15 option

This GAP product is a basic black roofing felt labeled 15 lb. Its simple product description makes it a practical choice to consider when your roofing plan calls for #15 felt and you do not need a product listing with extensive technical detail.

The main advantage is its clear grade designation. Before ordering, confirm the roll’s coverage, dimensions, and any installation requirements on the product page or packaging. The supplied listing does not provide those details, so it is harder to estimate how many rolls you will need from the title alone.

Compared with the #30 choices here, this is the lighter-grade option. Choose it only when it fits your roof system and local requirements; do not assume that one grade is suitable for every roof or climate.

Pros:

  • Clearly labeled as 15 lb. roofing felt
  • Simple option for projects specified for #15 felt
  • Black felt design

Cons:

  • Listing details do not specify roll coverage or dimensions
  • Not the right choice when your roof plan calls for #30 felt

Verdict: Choose this GAP roll when you need #15 black felt and can verify that its coverage and specifications suit your project.

TARCO STD15 36×144 #15 Asphalt Felt: A clearly identified standard roll

The TARCO STD15 is an asphalt felt product labeled #15. Its title gives a 36×144 designation, which offers more identifying information than listings that only state the felt grade. The supplied product details also identify Tarco as the brand and the United States as the country of origin.

That extra labeling can help when you are comparing material lists or trying to match a specified product. Still, check the listing to confirm the dimensions and usable coverage before you plan your order. The product data also gives a 32-pound item weight, which is useful to consider when arranging delivery or handling.

This is a sensible option for a project that calls for #15 asphalt felt. It is not a substitute for #30 felt where the roofing instructions require that heavier grade. As with any underlayment, follow the roof-covering manufacturer’s guidance and applicable local codes.

Pros:

  • Identified as #15 asphalt felt
  • Product title includes a 36×144 designation
  • Listing identifies the country of origin as the United States
  • Item weight is provided in the product details

Cons:

  • Confirm the listed dimensions and coverage before ordering
  • Not a #30 option for projects that specify the thicker grade

Verdict: Pick the TARCO STD15 when your project calls for #15 asphalt felt and its roll details match your material plan.

ORGILL 30RF Standard Roofing Felt: A thicker #30 choice

ORGILL’s 30RF is a standard roofing felt intended for use as an underlay beneath sloped coverings. The product description calls it a uniform, flexible felt made from organic fibers and says it meets the ASTM 4869 Type I standard. It also describes 30RF as twice the thickness of 15RF.

Those details make this one of the more clearly specified #30 choices in the group. The listing gives an approximate roll weight of 36 pounds, but it does not state coverage in the supplied information. Verify the roll size before estimating how much material your roof needs.

The #30 grade may suit a project where the plans call for thicker felt, but the grade alone does not determine whether it is right for your roof. Check the roofing material instructions and local requirements. Compared with the #15 products above, this felt is the more substantial option, while the other #30 listings identify roll dimensions or coverage more directly.

Pros:

  • Described as twice the thickness of 15RF
  • Listing states it meets ASTM 4869 Type I
  • Made from organic fibers and described as flexible
  • Designed for use beneath sloped roof coverings

Cons:

  • Supplied description does not state roll coverage
  • Its #30 grade may be more than a project calling for #15 needs

Verdict: Consider the ORGILL 30RF when your roof plan calls for #30 felt and you want a listing with clear material and standard information.

Tarco Std30 36×72 #30 Asphalt Felt: A heavier-grade roll format

This Tarco product is identified as STD30 #30 asphalt felt. Its title also includes a 36×72 roll designation, which can help distinguish it from the #15 product in the same comparison. The supplied listing does not include a fuller material description, so you will need to check the current product details for specifications before buying.

As a #30 option, it is aimed at projects where the heavier felt grade is called for. The roll designation may help with planning, but confirm the units and actual coverage on the listing or packaging rather than relying on the title alone. Also make sure it meets the requirements for your roof covering.

The supplied product data marks this listing as unavailable. If it remains out of stock, compare the available ORGILL and GAP #30 products, while checking that their coverage and specifications match your project.

Pros:

  • Clearly identified as #30 asphalt felt
  • Title includes a 36×72 designation
  • Tarco offers a separate #15 product in this comparison for grade matching

Cons:

  • Supplied listing is marked unavailable
  • Product description provides few technical details

Verdict: This Tarco roll is worth considering if it becomes available and its confirmed dimensions and specifications meet your project requirements.

GAP Roofing Black 216 sq. ft. #30 Felt: Coverage is stated in the title

This GAP product is listed as black #30 roofing felt, with 216 square feet included in its title. That coverage figure can make initial material planning easier than with listings that do not state coverage, though you should still confirm the current package details before ordering.

The #30 label makes this a heavier-grade alternative to the #15 GAP product above. It may be a closer fit when your plans specifically call for #30 felt, but the listing description supplied here provides little beyond the coverage title and country-of-origin note. Check for any additional product specifications you need.

The supplied product data marks this listing as unavailable. If you cannot buy it, the ORGILL 30RF is another #30 option in this comparison with more information about its material and stated standard. Do not assume the alternatives have the same coverage.

Pros:

  • Identified as black #30 roofing felt
  • Product title states 216 square feet of coverage
  • Useful grade alternative to the GAP #15 felt

Cons:

  • Supplied listing is marked unavailable
  • Product description offers limited technical detail

Verdict: Consider this GAP roll if it becomes available and your project calls for #30 felt, after confirming its package coverage and specifications.

How to Choose Felt Paper for Roofing

Match the felt grade to your roof plan

Start with the roof-covering manufacturer’s instructions and your local building requirements. These should guide whether you need #15 or #30 felt. The products in this roundup include both grades, and the ORGILL description specifically states that its 30RF is twice the thickness of 15RF. Do not select a grade based only on the idea that thicker is always better; use the grade required for your roof system.

Check the exact roll coverage

Roll dimensions and coverage affect how much material you need. One product title gives 216 square feet, while other listings use designations such as 36×144 or 36×72. Confirm what those measurements mean on the product page or packaging, and account for the overlap and waste required by your installation instructions.

Review the material and standards

Read the product description for details that matter to your project. For example, the ORGILL 30RF listing describes organic fibers and states that it meets ASTM 4869 Type I. Other product entries provide fewer technical details, so check the package or seller information if you need to confirm a specific material or standard.

Consider handling and delivery

Roofing felt is supplied in rolls, so weight and roll size can affect carrying, storage, and moving materials to the roof. The TARCO STD15 listing gives an item weight of 32 pounds, and the ORGILL 30RF listing describes a roll weight of about 36 pounds. Check the current listing for shipping and package details before making arrangements.

Compare availability and product information

Availability can change, and the supplied data marks both the Tarco Std30 and GAP #30 listings as unavailable. If your preferred option cannot be purchased, compare the specifications of available products rather than choosing by brand or grade alone. Similar titles do not guarantee the same coverage or product details.

Plan installation around the roofing instructions

Felt underlayment needs to be installed in a way that works with the roof covering and the roof’s construction. Follow the instructions for your shingles or other roof material, along with local code requirements. If you are unsure about the right underlayment or installation method, ask a qualified roofing professional before work begins.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between #15 and #30 roofing felt?

They are different felt grades. In this product group, the ORGILL description says 30RF is twice the thickness of 15RF. Follow your roofing instructions and local requirements to decide which grade is appropriate.

Is #30 roofing felt always the better choice?

No. A thicker grade is not automatically right for every roof. Use the grade specified for your roof covering and installation, and check local building requirements before buying.

How much coverage does one roll provide?

Coverage depends on the specific product. The GAP #30 title states 216 square feet, while other listings show roll designations or do not provide coverage in the supplied details. Confirm the package coverage and allow for installation overlap and waste.

Can I use roofing felt under any type of roof covering?

Do not assume that every felt product works with every roof covering. Check the roof-covering manufacturer’s instructions and local code to confirm the correct underlayment for your project.

Which product has the most detailed material information?

The ORGILL 30RF listing provides several details: it describes organic fibers, says the felt is flexible, states that it meets ASTM 4869 Type I, and compares its thickness with 15RF. Other products may have further details on their current listings or packaging.

What should I do if the product I want is unavailable?

Compare another available product in the same grade, then check its coverage, material details, and required standards. The supplied data marks two #30 listings as unavailable, so confirm current stock and specifications before you place an order.

Final Recommendation

For a straightforward #15 choice, compare the GAP Roofing 15 lb. felt with the TARCO STD15 and confirm the roll coverage that fits your project. If your plans call for #30 felt, the ORGILL 30RF stands out for its stated material information and ASTM reference. The GAP and Tarco #30 listings provide useful roll identifiers, but the supplied data marks them unavailable. In every case, let your roof system’s instructions and local requirements determine the right product.

Rate this post
Spread the love

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top