A fly screen dog door lets your pet move between the house and a screened porch or patio without leaving the screen door open. The right choice depends on your dog’s size, the opening dimensions, and how securely the flap closes. The options below include magnetic, lockable designs, but their size claims vary, so measure your pet and check the listed opening before you buy.
Table of Contents
Quick Comparison
| Product | Flap or opening size | Best suited for | Notable feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ownpets 12" x 14" Dog Screen Door | 12" x 14" opening | Owners seeking a roomy opening and two-sided locks | Magnetic flap and snap-on installation |
| PetSafe Large Screen Door | 8" W x 9.25" H, according to the description | Smaller pets, if the stated opening fits | Puncture- and tear-resistant mesh |
| Ownpets 11" x 13" Dog Screen Door | 11" x 13" inside size | Small or medium pets, based on the description | Magnetic flap with a lock |
Our Picks: Best Fly Screen Dog Door reviews
Ownpets 12" x 14": A Roomier Opening With Two-Sided Locks
This Ownpets model has a 12-by-14-inch opening, a magnetic self-closing flap, and locks on both sides. The larger opening may be more comfortable for a dog that finds smaller screen flaps awkward, but the product’s stated weight capacity should not replace a fit check: measure your dog’s shoulder width and height against the opening.
The frame is made from ABS plastic, with reinforced hinges and larger screws described as features intended to resist sagging and wear. Its listing says it works with metal, fiberglass, and vinyl-coated screens between 0.25 and 0.5 inches thick. It also describes a snap-on, tool-free setup and includes a template. Because the description mentions both snap-on installation and reinforcement screws, check the included instructions to confirm the exact installation steps for your screen.
The two-sided locking system is useful if you want to control access from either side of the door. The flap’s magnetic closure is intended to close behind your pet and help limit insects entering through the opening. As with any flap in a screen, its seal is not a substitute for a solid exterior door.
Pros:
- Roomy 12-by-14-inch opening
- Magnetic self-closing flap
- Locks accessible from both sides
- Listed for several common screen materials
Cons:
- The opening may still be too small for some large or broad-chested dogs
- Confirm the installation method and screen thickness before ordering
Verdict: Choose this Ownpets model if you want a larger flap and two-sided access control, provided your pet and screen match the listed dimensions and requirements.
PetSafe Screen Door: Tear-Resistant Mesh for Smaller Pets
The PetSafe screen door is designed to snap into an existing screen door, window, or porch screen. Its high-impact plastic frame surrounds mesh described as puncture- and tear-resistant, and the large version has fastening screws. These features may suit households where a pet pushes on or paws at the screen, though the flap still needs to match your pet’s size.
There is a notable sizing mismatch in the supplied product information: the title says the large model is for pets up to 100 pounds, while the description says it is for pets under 30 pounds and gives an opening of 8 inches wide by 9.25 inches high. Because those details do not agree, use the stated opening dimensions as a starting point and confirm the current specifications with the seller before choosing it for your dog.
The large door’s sliding wind-locks are described as helping keep the flap from blowing open while allowing a pet to pass through. The description also says the small door locks to prevent entry. This model is listed for most metal or vinyl-coated fiber screens, so check your screen material and thickness before installation.
Pros:
- Mesh is described as puncture- and tear-resistant
- Designed for screen doors, windows, and porch screens
- Large version includes fastening screws
- Wind-locks help resist the flap opening in a breeze
Cons:
- The title and description give conflicting weight guidance
- The stated opening is smaller than the openings on the Ownpets options
Verdict: Consider this PetSafe option for a smaller pet only after confirming the size and weight guidance, since its supplied listing details conflict.
Ownpets 11" x 13": A Lockable Magnetic Flap for Smaller Dogs
This Ownpets door has an 11-by-13-inch inside opening and a 17.3-by-13.4-inch outside frame. Its built-in magnets are intended to close the flap after a pet passes through, and the door can be locked when you want to limit access. The description lists it for screen doors, windows, porches, and other screen areas.
The frame is made from ABS plastic and is reinforced with screws, according to the product information. The listing describes the model as suitable for small or medium dogs, even though its title refers to a large dog. For that reason, treat the opening dimensions—not the title—as the main sizing guide, and measure your pet before ordering.
The description notes that the package does not include screen mesh. It suggests that the section of mesh cut from the screen can be fitted between the inner flap pieces to help keep mosquitoes out. This may be useful for an owner who wants to reuse the existing screen material, but follow the supplied instructions to confirm how it should be fitted.
Pros:
- Magnetic flap is designed to close automatically
- Lockable when you want to restrict access
- Reinforced ABS frame
- Listed for doors, windows, and porch screens
Cons:
- The description recommends it for small or medium dogs despite the title’s large-dog wording
- Screen mesh is not included
Verdict: This is a sensible option for a small or medium pet if the 11-by-13-inch opening fits and you are comfortable installing the frame into your existing screen.
How to Choose a Fly Screen Dog Door
Measure Your Pet and the Flap Opening
Check the clear opening dimensions rather than relying only on a product title or weight claim. Measure your dog’s shoulder width and height, then compare those measurements with the flap opening. Your pet should be able to pass through without squeezing or catching its back. If a listing gives conflicting size guidance, confirm the details with the seller before buying.
Check Your Screen Material and Thickness
Screen doors differ in material and frame construction. The 12-by-14-inch Ownpets model lists compatibility with metal, fiberglass, and vinyl-coated screens from 0.25 to 0.5 inches thick. PetSafe lists most metal or vinyl-coated fiber screens. Check the product’s compatibility details against your own screen, and avoid assuming that a door will fit just because it is described as universal.
Decide How You Want to Control Access
A magnetic flap can close behind your pet, while a lock can stop the pet from using the opening when needed. The larger Ownpets model has locks on both sides; the smaller Ownpets model is described as lockable. PetSafe’s description distinguishes between the large model’s wind-locks and the small model’s locking feature, so confirm which version you are considering.
Consider Flap Strength and Your Pet’s Habits
Material descriptions can help narrow your options. PetSafe describes its mesh as puncture- and tear-resistant, while the Ownpets models use ABS frames and mention reinforcement. These details do not mean a screen flap is indestructible. If your dog regularly scratches or leans hard on screens, consider how that behavior may affect both the pet door and the surrounding screen.
Understand Installation and What Is Included
Some models are described as snapping into an existing screen, while others mention screws or reinforcement. Check the instructions and included parts before starting, especially if you rent or want to avoid permanent changes. The 11-by-13-inch Ownpets listing says mesh is not included and describes reusing the cut screen material, so account for that when planning the installation.
Think About Bugs, Wind, and Weather
Magnetic closures and wind-locks can help keep a flap in place, but a pet opening is still a break in the screen. If insect control is important, check how the flap closes and whether the product instructions explain how to reuse or fit screen mesh. Do not treat a screen pet door as a replacement for a solid, weather-sealed exterior door.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a fly screen dog door fit any screen door?
No. Compatibility depends on the screen material, thickness, and available space. Check the product’s listed screen types and installation requirements against your door before ordering.
How do I choose the right flap size?
Measure your pet’s shoulder width and height, then compare those measurements with the clear opening. Choose an opening that lets your pet pass through comfortably instead of relying only on a weight limit.
Do magnetic flaps keep insects out?
A magnetic closure is designed to pull the flap shut after a pet passes through, which can help limit the gap. It does not create a perfect seal, so a screen pet door may still allow some insects through.
Can I install a pet door in a porch screen?
Some of these products are listed for porch screens as well as screen doors. Confirm the screen material and thickness requirements, and follow the product’s installation directions.
Can I lock the flap when my pet is inside?
The Ownpets models are described as lockable, with the 12-by-14-inch model listing locks on both sides. The PetSafe description mentions a lock for the small door and wind-locks for the large one. Check the specific model’s details before buying.
Does the PetSafe large model fit a dog up to 100 pounds?
The supplied title says up to 100 pounds, but the description says under 30 pounds and lists an 8-by-9.25-inch opening. Those details conflict. Confirm the current product specifications before buying it for a dog.
Final Recommendation
For a larger opening and two-sided access control, the Ownpets 12-by-14-inch model is the strongest option among these picks, as long as its opening and installation requirements suit your pet and screen. For a smaller pet, the Ownpets 11-by-13-inch model offers a magnetic flap and lockable design. The PetSafe option may work for a smaller animal, but its conflicting size details make it important to verify the specifications first.