A front door lock box can give family members, guests, cleaners, or caregivers access to a spare key without leaving it under a mat. The right choice depends on where you plan to attach it, how many keys you need to store, and whether you prefer a hanging shackle or a fixed wall mount. These five options range from a compact hanging box to models that can be mounted or hung, with different code styles and storage details.
Table of Contents
Quick Comparison
| Product | Style | Code | Key capacity | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Master Lock 5400EC Portable Key Lock Box | Hanging shackle | Resettable 4-digit | Up to 5 standard keys | Temporary access and door-knob use |
| GRIFEMA Wall-Mounted and Hanging Key Lock Box | Wall mount or hanging shackle | Resettable 4-digit | Up to 5 keys | Flexible mounting options |
| Vazioyar Portable and Wall-Mounted Key Lock Box | Wall mount or removable shackle | Resettable 4-digit | Up to 5 keys and an access card | Extra interior space |
| Master Lock 5401EC Wall-Mount Key Lock Box | Fixed wall mount | Resettable 4-digit | Up to 5 keys | A permanent, low-profile installation |
| Cididu Push-Button Key Lock Box | Removable hanging shackle | Push-button, set 4 to 8 digits | Key hook inside; capacity not specified | People who prefer buttons to dials |
Our Picks: Best Front Door Lock Box reviews
1. Master Lock 5400EC: A Simple Hanging Box for Spare Keys
The Master Lock 5400EC is a portable combination lock box that hangs from a door knob, gate, fence, or another suitable fixture. Its interior is sized for up to five standard house keys, and its vinyl-coated shackle is designed to help avoid scratching the surface it hangs from.
You set and reset the four-digit combination, so you can change the code when access needs change. A protective shutter covers the dials, and the metal body is intended for outdoor exposure. The shackle opening measures 1.1 inches wide by 1.69 inches tall, so check your door hardware before choosing this style.
This model suits households that want a removable box rather than a permanent installation. Its listed interior space is relatively compact, so it is best for standard keys rather than bulky fobs or several larger items. Compared with the wall-mounted Master Lock below, it is easier to move but depends on having a compatible place to hang it.
Pros:
- Holds up to five standard keys
- Resettable four-digit combination
- Vinyl-coated shackle fits many common knob styles
- Protective shutter covers the dials
Cons:
- Shackle dimensions may not fit every knob or handle
- Compact interior is not intended for bulky items
Verdict: Choose the 5400EC if you want a straightforward hanging box for standard spare keys and have a compatible knob or fixture.
2. GRIFEMA: A Flexible Box for Hanging or Wall Mounting
The GRIFEMA lock box offers two installation styles: use the included hardware to mount it to a wall, or attach its detachable metal shackle to a suitable door, gate, railing, or garage handle. That flexibility makes it useful if you may want to change its location or prefer a fixed position beside an entry.
It has a resettable four-digit code and a zinc-alloy body. The maker describes the box as weatherproof and includes a cover intended to shield the dials from outdoor conditions. Its interior is listed as large enough for five house or car keys, key fobs, credit cards, or USB drives, though actual fit depends on the size and shape of the items.
Compared with the Master Lock 5400EC, the GRIFEMA offers a wall-mount option and a stated capacity for small extras such as a fob. The trade-off is that its product information does not provide the same specific shackle-opening measurements, so measure your intended attachment point and confirm the fit before relying on it.
Pros:
- Can be wall-mounted or hung with its detachable shackle
- Resettable four-digit combination
- Stated capacity includes up to five keys and small items
- Protective cover shields the dials outdoors
Cons:
- Specific shackle-opening dimensions are not provided in the supplied details
- Fit for key fobs and other extras will depend on their size
Verdict: The GRIFEMA is a good fit if you want the choice of a fixed wall installation or a removable hanging setup.
3. Vazioyar: A Roomier Combination Box with Multiple Mounting Options
The Vazioyar is a combination lock box designed for outdoor or indoor use. Its listed interior dimensions are 3.54 by 2.64 by 1.2 inches, and it is described as holding up to five keys and an access card. That extra room may be useful if your access plan involves more than a single house key.
The box uses a resettable four-digit combination and offers a removable shackle plus wall-mounting hardware. Its product details also mention installation at a peephole, but that option may depend on the setup of your door, so check the instructions and mounting points before planning around it. The shell combines alloy and ABS plastic, with a cover intended to help shield it from rain, dust, and sun.
Compared with the Master Lock options, the Vazioyar gives specific interior dimensions and multiple installation methods. However, its product description does not provide measurements for the shackle opening or a detailed mounting layout. Confirm that the available hardware suits your intended location, and avoid treating any combination box as a substitute for a secure door lock.
Pros:
- Listed interior dimensions make it easier to assess storage space
- Designed to hold up to five keys and an access card
- Offers a removable shackle and wall-mount installation
- Resettable four-digit combination
Cons:
- Shackle-opening measurements are not listed in the supplied details
- Multiple installation options may require checking the fit at your specific location
Verdict: Consider the Vazioyar if you want a roomier box with both hanging and fixed mounting options, and its stated dimensions suit your items.
4. Master Lock 5401EC: A Fixed Wall-Mount Box for Regular Access
The Master Lock 5401EC is a wall-mounted lock box for people who want a set location for a spare key. Mounting hardware is included, and its low-profile design is intended to sit beside a door, garage, or gate. Unlike the 5400EC, it does not rely on a door knob or handle for support.
Its interior measures 3.25 inches high by 2.25 inches wide by 1 inch deep, with space for up to five keys. The four-digit combination can be reset, and a protective shutter covers the dials. The reinforced metal body is designed to resist hammering and sawing, but a lock box should still be placed discreetly and used as part of a broader home-access plan.
This is the most clearly specified choice in the lineup for a permanent wall installation: the product details include both interior and exterior dimensions. The main trade-off is that it takes more effort to install than a hanging box and is less convenient to move once fixed in place.
Pros:
- Includes hardware for wall mounting
- Interior dimensions are provided for checking key fit
- Holds up to five keys
- Resettable combination and protective dial shutter
Cons:
- Requires a suitable surface and installation
- Less portable than a hanging-shackle model
Verdict: Pick the 5401EC if you want a fixed, measured-to-fit key box rather than one hanging from your door hardware.
5. Cididu: A Push-Button Box with a Removable Shackle
The Cididu differs from the dial-style boxes in this roundup: it uses push buttons and a removable shackle. Its combination can be set from four to eight digits, and an interior hook is included to help keep keys in place. The shackle is designed to attach to door handles, fences, and other suitable fixtures.
The aluminum-alloy body has a protective cover intended to help keep dust and weather away from the buttons. One important detail is that the supplied product information says the buttons can be pressed in any order once the correct digits are used. That means the entry pattern is not based on the order of the numbers, so choose a code with that limitation in mind.
The Cididu may suit someone who prefers buttons to turning combination dials. However, its key capacity and interior dimensions are not specified in the supplied details, making it harder to judge whether it will fit several keys or larger items. The instructions also warn that forgetting the code can prevent access, so store the combination securely.
Pros:
- Push-button entry instead of combination dials
- Combination can be set from four to eight digits
- Removable shackle allows hanging on a suitable fixture
- Interior key hook helps organize stored keys
Cons:
- Buttons can be pressed in any order, which limits code-entry sequence options
- Key capacity and interior dimensions are not specified in the supplied details
Verdict: Choose the Cididu if you prefer push buttons and the any-order code behavior works for your access needs.
How to Choose a Front Door Lock Box
Choose a hanging or wall-mounted design
A hanging lock box is quick to place and does not require mounting hardware, but it only works if the shackle fits your knob, handle, gate, or railing. A wall-mounted box stays in one place and avoids dependence on door hardware, but you need a suitable mounting surface and must install it correctly. If you want both options, look for a model that includes a removable shackle and wall-mount hardware.
Check the opening and storage dimensions
Capacity claims do not tell the whole story. A box that holds several standard keys may not fit a bulky car fob, access card, or key with a large plastic head. Compare the interior dimensions with the items you plan to store. For hanging models, also measure the intended fixture and compare it with the shackle opening where dimensions are available.
Pick a code style you can use reliably
Most models here use resettable four-digit combinations, while the Cididu uses buttons and allows a code of four to eight digits. Choose a format that is easy for authorized visitors to understand and enter. Keep the combination somewhere secure, and change it when a guest, worker, or other temporary user no longer needs access.
Consider where the box will be exposed
Outdoor models may include a cover or shutter to help protect their controls from rain, dust, and sunlight. Those features can help with exposure, but they do not make a lock box impossible to damage or guarantee protection in every condition. Follow the product instructions, and choose a placement that is reasonably sheltered and not easy to spot from the street.
Think about access control and placement
A lock box makes a spare key available to people who know the code, so limit code sharing to people you trust. Place the box where authorized users can reach it, but avoid an obvious location beside the front door if a less visible suitable spot is available. A lock box is for controlled key storage; it does not replace the deadbolt or other security on your door.
Match the box to how often you will use it
For occasional visits or temporary access, a portable shackle model can be convenient. For regular use by household members, renters, or service providers, a fixed wall mount may give you a consistent access point. If different people need access over time, a resettable code can make it easier to update entry details without replacing the box.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are front door lock boxes safe for storing a spare key?
They can provide controlled access without leaving a key under a mat, but no lock box should be treated as impossible to break into. Use a strong, private code, place the box thoughtfully, and keep your main door lock secure.
Can a lock box hang on any front door knob?
No. Fit depends on the knob or handle shape and the shackle opening. Check the product’s listed shackle dimensions against your hardware before buying. Wall-mounted models avoid the need to fit a door knob.
How many keys fit inside these lock boxes?
The Master Lock 5400EC, GRIFEMA, Vazioyar, and Master Lock 5401EC are described as holding up to five keys, though the exact fit depends on key size. The Cididu product details do not specify a key capacity.
Can I reset the combination?
The four-digit models in this roundup are described as resettable. The Cididu lets you set a four- to eight-digit button combination. Follow the product instructions when setting or changing a code, and record it securely.
Is a hanging box or wall-mounted box better?
Neither style is best for every home. A hanging box is easier to move but needs a compatible fixture. A wall-mounted box stays in a consistent place but requires a suitable surface and installation.
Will these lock boxes protect keys from rain?
Several models include a protective cover or shutter and are described as suitable for outdoor use. These features are meant to shield the controls from the elements, but outdoor exposure and placement can affect how well any box holds up over time.
Final Recommendation
For a fixed installation with clearly stated interior dimensions, the Master Lock 5401EC is a practical choice. If you want flexibility between hanging and wall mounting, consider the GRIFEMA or Vazioyar. The Master Lock 5400EC is a straightforward option for a compatible door knob, while the Cididu stands out for its push-button format. Before choosing, verify the fit, decide how many keys you need to store, and consider who will receive the code.