A gas-fired tankless water heater can save space and heat water only when you need it, but choosing the right model depends on how many fixtures you use at once and how cold your incoming water is. The options below range from compact units for smaller households to high-capacity models designed for several bathrooms. Compare their flow rates, efficiency figures, installation needs, and fuel compatibility before deciding.
Table of Contents
Quick Comparison
| Model | Rated flow and output | Efficiency | Best suited for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rheem RTG Series 7.0 GPM | 7.0 GPM at a 35°F rise; 160,000 BTU | 0.82 UEF | Homes needing a non-condensing whole-house unit |
| APUS 4.42 GPM Natural Gas Tankless | 4.42 GPM; 95,000 BTU | 0.81 UEF; up to 98% thermal efficiency claimed | Smaller homes with moderate simultaneous demand |
| Rinnai RX199iN | Up to 11.1 GPM; 199,000 BTU | 0.98 UEF | Large homes and buyers who want fuel flexibility |
| ThermoMate CZ422NG | Up to 5 GPM; 102,000 BTU | 0.81 UEF; up to 98% thermal efficiency claimed | Homes with moderate demand and limited installation space |
| Rheem RTGH Series 8.4 GPM | 8.4 GPM at a 35°F rise; 157,000 BTU | 0.93 UEF | Large households seeking a high-efficiency indoor unit |
Flow rates depend on incoming water temperature and the temperature rise your home needs. Confirm sizing and installation requirements with a qualified professional.
Our Picks: Best Gas Fired Water Heater reviews
1. Rheem RTG Series: A Non-Condensing Option for Whole-Home Use
The Rheem RTG is an indoor, natural-gas tankless heater rated for 7.0 GPM at a 35°F temperature rise, with a 160,000 BTU input. Rheem positions it for whole-house use, including homes where two or three hot-water fixtures may run at the same time. That flow rating is tied to the stated temperature rise, so colder incoming water can affect how much hot water the unit can deliver.
This is a non-condensing model with a 0.82 UEF and a direct-vent design. It mounts on a wall, which can free up floor space compared with a storage tank. The digital control lets you adjust the set temperature in small increments, and the listed features include freeze protection, flame-failure protection, and LeakGuard leak detection and prevention.
Its main appeal is a balance of capacity and a simpler non-condensing design compared with the higher-efficiency condensing Rheem below. It may suit a household replacing an older tank heater, but a professional should confirm the vent setup, gas supply, and local installation requirements before purchase.
Pros:
- Rated for 7.0 GPM at a 35°F rise
- Wall-mounted design helps conserve floor space
- Includes listed freeze, flame-failure, and leak protections
- Digital temperature adjustment in 1°F increments
Cons:
- Its 0.82 UEF is lower than the condensing Rinnai and Rheem models here
- Capacity can fall when a larger temperature rise is needed
Verdict: Choose the Rheem RTG if you want a whole-house natural-gas tankless heater with solid stated capacity and do not need the highest efficiency figure in this group.
2. APUS 4.42 GPM: A Compact Pick for Moderate Hot-Water Demand
The APUS is an indoor natural-gas tankless heater rated at 95,000 BTU and 4.42 GPM. Its listed capacity is aimed at moderate household demand, such as two showers and a sink running together. The maker also specifies a low-flow start at 0.66 GPM, which can help the unit activate when water use is modest.
It has a compact listed size of 20.55 inches high, 13.27 inches wide, and 5.91 inches deep, along with an LED touchscreen and a temperature setting range of 95°F to 140°F. APUS lists a 0.81 UEF and claims up to 98% thermal efficiency. These are different efficiency measures, so compare the UEF figures when evaluating the models in this guide.
The built-in freeze protection is a useful feature, but the product information also says to drain the unit if it will be unused for a long time to help prevent freeze damage. With less rated output than the larger Rheem and Rinnai options, this model is a better match for a smaller household than a home with heavy, overlapping demand.
Pros:
- Compact indoor design with touchscreen controls
- Low-flow start is listed at 0.66 GPM
- Temperature can be set from 95°F to 140°F
- Designed to serve multiple fixtures within its rated capacity
Cons:
- Lower rated flow and BTU output than the larger whole-house choices
- Long periods of non-use may require draining in cold conditions
Verdict: Consider the APUS for a compact setup and moderate hot-water use, but compare its output carefully with your household’s busiest periods.
3. Rinnai RX199iN: The Highest-Capacity Pick for Larger Homes
The Rinnai RX199iN is the highest-capacity option in this lineup, with 199,000 BTU and a stated maximum flow of 11.1 GPM. Rinnai says it can serve up to seven fixtures at once, though real output depends on incoming water temperature, the required temperature rise, and the fixtures being used. Its condensing design has a listed 0.98 UEF, the highest UEF among these picks.
Smart Sense lets this model run on either natural gas or propane, and the product is designed for indoor or outdoor installation. Outdoor installation requires the RX-OVC vent cap. The unit also includes a Quick Flush feature intended to make flushing simpler. Wi-Fi control is not built in as standard; the listing identifies a separate Controlr module for that function.
This is a strong fit for a large household that needs substantial simultaneous output and wants the fuel flexibility. The tradeoff is a more involved installation: Rinnai recommends professional installation, and your installer should confirm the venting arrangement, fuel setup, and local requirements. Its listed residential warranty includes 15 years on the heat exchanger and five years on parts; the five-year labor coverage requires registration within 90 days, or it defaults to one year.
Pros:
- Highest stated flow capacity in this comparison
- 0.98 UEF is the highest listed UEF here
- Smart Sense supports natural gas or propane
- Designed for indoor or outdoor installation with the specified outdoor vent cap
Cons:
- Outdoor installation requires a separate specified vent cap
- Wi-Fi control requires an additional module
Verdict: The Rinnai RX199iN is the best match here for a large home with high simultaneous demand, provided its installation needs and added controls fit your plans.
4. ThermoMate CZ422NG: A Space-Saving Indoor Unit with Detailed Controls
The ThermoMate CZ422NG is an indoor natural-gas model rated for up to 5 GPM and 102,000 BTU. Its product information describes serving two showers at once while maintaining 105°F with 65°F incoming water. That condition matters: colder inlet water calls for a larger temperature rise and may reduce the flow available at the desired temperature.
At 21 inches high, 13 inches wide, and 7 inches deep, it is a compact alternative to a storage tank. It includes a 3.5-inch LED display for temperature and operating information, with a listed adjustment range of 90°F to 140°F. The manufacturer lists a 0.81 UEF and claims up to 98% thermal efficiency, as well as freeze protection and several safety shutdown protections.
The supplied specifications also call out standard 3/4-inch water connections, a 1/2-inch gas inlet, a 3-inch vent connection, and a 120V plug. These details are useful for an installer to check, but they do not guarantee compatibility with your existing setup. Its stated capacity is between the APUS and larger Rheem models, making it a possible fit for a household with moderate demand.
Pros:
- Compact dimensions and a diagnostic display
- Rated for up to 5 GPM and 102,000 BTU
- Temperature setting range of 90°F to 140°F
- Lists freeze protection and multiple safety protections
Cons:
- Listed two-shower performance is based on a stated 65°F inlet temperature
- Lower maximum flow than the larger Rheem and Rinnai models
Verdict: Choose the ThermoMate if its moderate capacity matches your needs and you value a compact unit with on-device diagnostic information.
5. Rheem RTGH Series: A More Efficient Condensing Rheem
The Rheem RTGH is an indoor, natural-gas condensing tankless heater rated for 8.4 GPM at a 35°F rise, with 157,000 BTU of input. Rheem describes it as suitable for three or four simultaneous showers. As with any tankless model, that kind of use depends on the incoming water temperature and the total flow and temperature needs of your fixtures.
Its 0.93 UEF is higher than the non-condensing Rheem RTG’s 0.82 UEF, while its stated flow at the same 35°F rise is also higher. Rheem lists direct venting, low-NOx emissions compliance, freeze protection, and digital temperature control with 1°F adjustments. The listed warranty is 15 years on the heat exchanger and five years on parts.
The higher efficiency figure makes this a compelling alternative to the Rinnai for households that want strong capacity in an indoor-only Rheem model. Condensing systems have different installation considerations from non-condensing units, so have a qualified professional confirm venting and any other requirements for your home.
Pros:
- Rated for 8.4 GPM at a 35°F rise
- 0.93 UEF is higher than the other Rheem model in this guide
- Digital temperature adjustment in 1°F increments
- Listed 15-year heat exchanger and five-year parts warranty
Cons:
- Rated flow is tied to the stated 35°F temperature rise
- Requires an installer to confirm condensing-system venting and compatibility
Verdict: The Rheem RTGH is a strong choice for a larger household that wants more capacity and a higher UEF than the non-condensing Rheem RTG.
How to Choose a Gas-Fired Water Heater
Size the heater for simultaneous use
Think about the busiest time of day, not just your average water use. Add up the flow needed for the fixtures you may run together, such as showers, a sink, or a dishwasher. Then compare that demand with the heater’s output. A model’s maximum GPM is not a guarantee that it will deliver that flow under every condition.
Account for incoming water temperature
A tankless heater must raise incoming water to your chosen temperature. The colder the supply water, the more work the heater has to do, which can reduce the flow it can deliver. Check whether a listed GPM figure is tied to a stated temperature rise, as it is for both Rheem models here, and ask an installer to size the unit for your local conditions.
Compare efficiency figures carefully
Uniform Energy Factor (UEF) is useful for comparing the listed energy performance of these models. The two compact models also advertise thermal-efficiency figures, but thermal efficiency and UEF are not the same measure. Compare like with like, and consider expected hot-water use when weighing efficiency against the unit’s capacity and installation needs.
Check fuel type and gas supply
Most models in this guide are listed for natural gas. The Rinnai RX199iN supports either natural gas or propane through its Smart Sense system. Before you buy, verify that the model matches your home’s fuel and that the gas supply and connections are suitable for the heater’s input. A qualified professional can assess the existing setup.
Plan for venting and installation space
Indoor gas heaters need an appropriate exhaust and venting arrangement. These products differ in their designs, and the Rinnai’s outdoor installation requires its specified RX-OVC vent cap. Check the product requirements with an installer before assuming the heater will fit your current location. Local permits and installation rules may also apply.
Consider freeze protection and maintenance
Several models list built-in freeze protection, but this feature does not remove every risk in a cold or unheated location. The APUS product information, for example, says to drain the unit if it will be unused for a long time. Ask about the manufacturer’s maintenance instructions, including flushing needs, before choosing a model.
Review controls, warranty, and added equipment
Compare how each heater handles temperature adjustment and troubleshooting. The Rheem models list digital controls, while the ThermoMate and APUS include display or touchscreen features. The Rinnai supports Wi-Fi control through a separate module. Also read the full warranty terms: coverage may vary by part and can depend on registration or installation conditions.
Frequently Asked Questions
What size gas tankless water heater do I need?
Choose a heater based on the fixtures you expect to use at the same time and the temperature rise needed in your home. A plumber or qualified installer can calculate the required flow and compare it with the model’s output under your local water conditions.
Can a tankless gas heater run more than one shower?
Yes, if its output is high enough for the combined flow and temperature needs. The APUS and ThermoMate listings describe use with multiple fixtures under stated conditions, while the larger Rheem and Rinnai models are designed for higher demand. Colder incoming water can reduce available flow.
Does a higher GPM rating always mean better performance?
No. A GPM rating needs context, including the temperature rise at which it was measured. Compare the heater’s output with your actual incoming water temperature and household demand rather than relying on the maximum flow figure alone.
What is the difference between condensing and non-condensing models?
A condensing heater is designed to capture more heat from exhaust gases, which can support a higher efficiency figure. In this group, the Rheem RTGH and Rinnai RX199iN are condensing models, while the Rheem RTG is non-condensing. Their venting and installation requirements can differ, so confirm details with an installer.
Can I install a gas tankless water heater myself?
Installation involves gas, water, electrical, and venting connections, and local rules may require permits or qualified installation. Rinnai specifically recommends professional installation. For any model, have a qualified professional confirm the setup and follow the manufacturer’s instructions.
Will a tankless heater provide unlimited hot water?
A tankless heater can keep heating water while it runs, but its flow capacity is limited. If your household uses more hot water at once than the heater can heat to the desired temperature, you may notice reduced flow or less hot water than expected.
Final Recommendation
For a large household with heavy simultaneous demand, the Rinnai RX199iN has the highest stated flow and UEF in this comparison, along with natural-gas or propane support. The Rheem RTGH is a strong indoor alternative with an 8.4 GPM rating at a 35°F rise and a 0.93 UEF. For more moderate needs, consider the compact APUS or ThermoMate, or the non-condensing Rheem RTG if its capacity and installation design better suit your home. Before ordering, confirm sizing, fuel, venting, and installation requirements with a qualified professional.