The best kind of shower curtain liner depends on what matters most in your bathroom: easy cleaning, a heavier drape, magnets that help hold the liner to a tub, or a softer material. For many homes, a waterproof PEVA liner is a simple, practical choice. We compare five options, including a thick weighted design and a colorful EVA liner, so you can match the material and features to your shower.
| Product | Material | Standout feature | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barossa Design PEVA Liner | PEVA | Three bottom magnets and rustproof grommets | A straightforward, clear liner |
| Mrs Awesome Clear PEVA Liner | PEVA | Encased magnets and reinforced header | A lightweight liner for a magnetic tub |
| BigFoot Heavy-Duty PEVA Curtain | 8G PEVA | Weighted bottom hem | A heavier drape with less billowing |
| AmazerBath EVA Curtain and Liner | EVA | Weighted stones and colorful design | A softer, decorative 2-in-1 option |
| LiBa PEVA Shower Curtain | PEVA | Smooth surface designed to shed water | A simple waterproof curtain |
Table of Contents
Our Picks: Best Kind Of Shower Curtain Liner reviews
Barossa Design PEVA Liner: A practical clear everyday pick
The Barossa Design liner is a clear, standard-size PEVA option intended to keep shower water inside the tub. Its lightweight material is designed to dry quickly and can also be used as a stand-alone curtain. The product title identifies it as Oeko-Tex certified; check the listing for certification details if that matters to your purchase.
It has 12 rustproof metal grommet holes, a reinforced header, and three magnets at the bottom. Those magnets are intended for iron-core bathtubs, where they can help keep the liner from shifting. They may not attach to tubs made of nonmagnetic materials, so the magnets should be viewed as a useful extra rather than a universal solution.
Compared with heavier choices like the BigFoot, this liner puts more emphasis on a light, simple design than on a weighted drape. Its clear finish lets light through, but it offers little visual privacy when used by itself. It is a good fit if you want a basic waterproof barrier or plan to pair it with a decorative outer curtain.
Pros:
- Waterproof PEVA surface is designed to dry quickly.
- Three magnets can help secure it to an iron-core tub.
- Reinforced header and rustproof metal grommets support hanging.
- Can be used alone or behind an outer curtain.
Cons:
- Magnets may not hold on a nonmagnetic tub.
- The clear finish provides little privacy when used alone.
Verdict: Choose the Barossa Design liner if you want a lightweight, clear PEVA curtain with basic reinforcement and magnets for a compatible tub.
Mrs Awesome Clear PEVA Liner: Lightweight with encased magnets
This 72-by-72-inch liner is made from PEVA and is designed to be lightweight and easy to fold. Its waterproof surface is intended to form water beads and can be wiped with a damp cloth. That simple care routine suits a busy bathroom, though wiping it down does not remove the need for regular cleaning.
The liner includes three encased magnets at the bottom, plus 12 rustproof metal grommets and a reinforced top header. The magnets are most useful with a cast-iron or other compatible magnetic tub. Like the Barossa Design option, this clear liner lets light pass through but does not provide much privacy on its own.
Its feature set is close to the Barossa Design liner, so the choice between them may come down to preference and the current listing details. Mrs Awesome highlights encased magnets and flexibility, while both are standard-size PEVA options with reinforced hanging areas. If you need a heavier curtain that resists billowing, the BigFoot or AmazerBath design is a more targeted choice.
Pros:
- Waterproof PEVA surface can be wiped clean.
- Encased magnets are designed to help hold the liner against a compatible tub.
- Reinforced header and 12 rustproof metal grommets support hanging.
- Standard 72-by-72-inch size suits many shower setups.
Cons:
- Magnets may not attach to tubs that are not magnetic.
- Clear material offers limited privacy as a stand-alone curtain.
Verdict: Pick the Mrs Awesome liner if you want a flexible, lightweight PEVA option with encased magnets for a compatible tub.
BigFoot Heavy-Duty PEVA Curtain: A weighted option to reduce billowing
BigFoot’s clear curtain uses 8G PEVA, described as a heavy-duty material intended to resist rips and tears. A reinforced top header and metal grommets provide a sturdier hanging area than a simple, unreinforced sheet. The listing describes the 72-by-72-inch curtain as washable, though it does not specify a washing method in the supplied details.
Instead of relying on magnets, this design uses a weighted bottom hem to help the curtain hang straight and reduce billowing or clinging. That may be useful if a light liner tends to move around during a shower. The smooth PEVA surface is also treated to resist buildup, but that should not be taken to mean it never needs cleaning.
Compared with the Barossa Design and Mrs Awesome liners, BigFoot prioritizes thickness and weight over a lightweight feel. The trade-off is that a heavier curtain may feel less convenient to handle than a thin liner. It is also clear, so it works best when paired with an outer curtain if you want more privacy or color.
Pros:
- 8G PEVA is designed to resist rips and tears.
- Weighted bottom hem helps limit billowing and clinging.
- Reinforced header and metal grommets support secure hanging.
- Listing describes the curtain as washable and treated to resist buildup.
Cons:
- Its heavier construction may be less convenient to handle than a lightweight liner.
- The clear design offers little privacy when used alone.
Verdict: Choose BigFoot if you prefer a thicker PEVA curtain with a weighted hem rather than magnets to help keep it in place.
AmazerBath EVA Curtain and Liner: A softer, colorful 2-in-1 design
AmazerBath’s 72-by-72-inch curtain is made from EVA and is designed to serve as either a decorative curtain or an inner liner. Its listing describes the material as silky soft, clear, and free of BPA, with a colorful design that lets light through. This makes it a more visually distinctive choice than the plain clear PEVA options.
For hanging, it has 12 larger brass grommets and a wide, double-layered reinforced header. Three weighted stones at the bottom are intended to keep the curtain from blowing or sticking to your body. Unlike the PEVA liners that rely on magnets, this design uses weights, so it does not depend on a magnetic tub.
The EVA material and colorful look may suit someone who wants one curtain to do both decorative and water-blocking work. The color-forward design may be less suitable if you want a nearly invisible liner or prefer to use a separate outer curtain. The product is also positioned as a heavier option, so it is not the pick for shoppers who value the lightest possible curtain.
Pros:
- EVA material is described as soft and quick-drying.
- Weighted stones help reduce billowing without relying on tub magnets.
- Large brass grommets and a wide reinforced header support hanging.
- Can be used as a decorative curtain or as a liner.
Cons:
- The colorful design may not suit a minimalist or nearly invisible look.
- Its heavier construction may not appeal if you want a very lightweight liner.
Verdict: Choose AmazerBath if you want an EVA curtain with a colorful appearance, weighted bottom, and the flexibility to use it as a curtain or liner.
LiBa PEVA Shower Curtain: A simple water-shedding design
LiBa’s 72-by-72-inch curtain is a PEVA option with a smooth surface designed to help water bead and roll away. The listing describes it as waterproof and offers three color options. It can be used by itself for a bright, open look or paired with an outer fabric curtain.
This is the most straightforward choice in the group: the supplied product details focus on water management and color options rather than magnets, weights, or specific grommet construction. If those hanging or anti-billowing features matter to you, compare the listing carefully with the Barossa Design, Mrs Awesome, BigFoot, or AmazerBath options before deciding.
LiBa may suit shoppers who want a standard-size plastic curtain without a prominent decorative design. As with other clear options, it provides little privacy on its own. The supplied details also do not specify features such as magnets or a reinforced header, so do not assume it includes them without checking the product listing.
Pros:
- Smooth PEVA surface is designed to shed water.
- Waterproof curtain can be used alone or with an outer curtain.
- Standard 72-by-72-inch size fits many common shower setups.
- Available in three color options according to the listing.
Cons:
- The supplied details do not specify magnets or a weighted hem.
- A clear version offers limited privacy when used alone.
Verdict: Pick LiBa if you want a simple PEVA curtain designed to shed water and do not need a specified weighted or magnetic bottom.
How to Choose the Best Shower Curtain Liner
Choose a material that fits your priorities
PEVA is a common choice when you want a waterproof, lightweight liner that is easy to wipe clean. EVA is another plastic option; the AmazerBath liner is described as softer and is designed to work as either a decorative curtain or an inner liner. Compare the specific product details rather than assuming all liners made from the same material have the same thickness, feel, or construction.
Check the size and how it will hang
Several options here are 72 by 72 inches, a standard size for many tubs and shower rods. Measure your shower opening and consider the rod height before ordering. A curtain that is too short may not keep water in the tub, while extra width can affect how it gathers. Also check the grommet layout and confirm that your hooks or rings are compatible.
Decide between magnets and a weighted hem
Magnets can help hold a liner against a compatible metal tub, but they may not stick to other tub materials. Weighted hems and stones offer a different way to limit billowing without relying on a magnetic surface. If the curtain tends to cling or move during a shower, a weighted design such as BigFoot or AmazerBath may be worth considering.
Look for a sturdy top edge
The top of a liner takes the strain from its hooks, so a reinforced header and durable grommets can be useful features. Barossa Design, Mrs Awesome, BigFoot, and AmazerBath specify reinforcement or sturdier hanging details. When a product listing does not describe the header or grommets, check the details before buying if long-term hanging strength is important to you.
Consider privacy and appearance
A clear liner lets light through and works well behind a decorative curtain, but it provides little privacy when used alone. A colorful or patterned design can add decoration while still serving as a water barrier. Think about whether you want the liner to disappear behind an outer curtain or act as a visible part of the bathroom.
Think about cleaning and upkeep
Many plastic liners can be wiped with a damp cloth, and some are described as quick-drying or washable. Follow the care instructions for the specific product rather than assuming every liner can go in a washing machine. Regular cleaning is still important, even when a surface is treated to resist buildup.
Match the weight to your daily use
A lightweight liner is easy to move and fold, while a heavier one may hang more steadily. Consider whether you value easy handling or a curtain that is designed to resist billowing. The best balance depends on your shower, the material of your tub, and whether you use an outer curtain.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best kind of shower curtain liner for most bathrooms?
A waterproof PEVA liner is a practical starting point for many bathrooms because it is designed to keep water in the tub and is often easy to wipe clean. Choose a model with magnets or a weighted bottom if you also want help keeping the liner in place.
Is PEVA or EVA better for a shower curtain liner?
Neither is automatically best for everyone. These products show that both materials can be used for waterproof curtains, but features and feel vary by design. Compare the specific curtain’s thickness, weight, cleaning instructions, and hanging details alongside the material.
Do shower curtain magnets work with every bathtub?
No. Magnets are intended to attach to compatible magnetic surfaces, such as certain iron-core or cast-iron tubs. If your tub is not magnetic, look for a weighted hem or weighted stones instead.
Will a clear liner provide privacy?
Usually not much. Clear liners let light through and are often designed to sit behind a decorative outer curtain. If you plan to use the liner by itself and want more privacy, look for an option with an opaque or decorative finish.
How do I stop a shower curtain liner from billowing?
Consider a liner with a weighted hem or weighted stones, or use magnets if your tub is compatible. A properly sized curtain that reaches into the tub can also help keep water contained. No single feature guarantees that a curtain will never move.
Can I use a shower curtain liner as the outer curtain?
Some can. Barossa Design and LiBa describe their curtains as suitable for stand-alone use, while AmazerBath is positioned as a 2-in-1 curtain and liner. Check the specific product details and consider whether its appearance and privacy level work for your bathroom.
Final Recommendation
For a straightforward, clear liner with magnets and reinforced hanging details, the Barossa Design PEVA liner is a well-rounded choice for a compatible tub. If keeping the curtain from billowing is your main concern, compare BigFoot’s weighted hem with AmazerBath’s weighted stones. For a more decorative look, AmazerBath stands apart with its colorful EVA design. Before buying, confirm the dimensions, tub compatibility, and care instructions that matter most for your shower.
