Choosing the best low-NOx water heater starts with matching the unit to your home’s fuel, hot-water demand, and installation location. The options below are condensing tankless models: two Rheem indoor units and one A. O. Smith outdoor unit. Compare their fuel type and stated flow rates carefully, since a higher GPM figure does not guarantee the same output under every incoming-water temperature or household demand.
Table of Contents
Quick Comparison
| Product | Fuel and installation | Stated flow rate | Best fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rheem RTGH 6.8 GPM Natural Gas | Natural gas, indoor | 6.8 GPM at a 35°F rise | Smaller households or homes with moderate hot-water demand |
| Rheem RTGH 9.5 GPM Propane | Liquid propane, indoor | 9.5 GPM at a 35°F rise | Homes needing more simultaneous hot-water capacity |
| A. O. Smith ProLine XE ATO-140H | Natural gas, outdoor | Up to 6.6 GPM | One- or two-bath homes suited to outdoor installation |
Our Picks: Best Low Nox Water Heater reviews
Rheem RTGH 6.8 GPM: Indoor Natural Gas for Moderate Demand
This Rheem is an indoor, natural-gas tankless water heater rated at 6.8 GPM with a 35°F temperature rise. Its 120,000 BTU-per-hour input and condensing design are intended to provide on-demand hot water while using less energy than a conventional storage tank, according to the product information.
The unit has direct-vent installation, built-in freeze protection, and a digital temperature control with stated precision of ±1°F. The product information lists a 0.93 Uniform Energy Factor, a 15-year heat-exchanger warranty, and a five-year parts warranty. It is described as suitable for two to three simultaneous showers, though actual output depends on incoming-water temperature and the total flow of fixtures running at once.
This is the natural-gas indoor choice for a household that does not need the higher stated capacity of the propane Rheem. It may suit a home with moderate demand, but the indoor location and direct-vent setup make planning important. The listing recommends professional installation, and you should confirm the required venting, gas supply, and local low-NOx rules before choosing it.
Pros:
- Natural-gas model with a stated 6.8 GPM flow rate at a 35°F rise
- Condensing design and stated 0.93 UEF
- Digital temperature control and built-in freeze protection
- Long heat-exchanger warranty listed by the manufacturer
Cons:
- Requires indoor space and a compatible direct-vent installation
- Lower stated flow capacity than the 9.5 GPM Rheem propane model
Verdict: Choose this Rheem if your home uses natural gas, needs an indoor unit, and has moderate hot-water demand; look elsewhere if you need the higher stated capacity of the propane model.
Rheem RTGH 9.5 GPM: Higher-Capacity Indoor Propane Model
This Rheem is the highest-capacity option in this group, with a stated flow rate of 9.5 GPM at a 35°F rise. It runs on liquid propane and is designed for indoor installation. Its 199,900 BTU-per-hour input and condensing technology make it the option to consider when several hot-water fixtures may run at the same time.
Like the smaller Rheem, it has direct venting, a digital LED temperature control with stated ±1°F precision, built-in freeze protection, and a multi-point safety system. The product information lists a 0.93 UEF and says the unit is intended for three to four simultaneous showers. That is a guide, not a guarantee: fixture flow and the temperature of the incoming water affect how much hot water the heater can deliver at once.
The main trade-off is fuel compatibility. This model is for liquid propane, not natural gas, so it is only a practical choice if your home has a suitable propane supply. Its higher stated capacity also does not automatically make it the right fit for every house; have an installer size the unit to your peak demand and confirm the venting and installation requirements.
Pros:
- Highest stated flow rate among these three options
- Designed for homes with greater simultaneous hot-water demand
- Condensing design, digital temperature control, and freeze protection
- 15-year heat-exchanger warranty and five-year parts warranty listed
Cons:
- Uses liquid propane, so it is not suitable for a natural-gas-only home
- Indoor direct-vent installation needs careful planning and professional setup
Verdict: This is the strongest match for a propane-equipped home that needs more simultaneous hot-water capacity, provided your installer confirms the sizing and venting are right.
A. O. Smith ProLine XE ATO-140H: Outdoor Natural Gas Option
The A. O. Smith ProLine XE ATO-140H is an outdoor, natural-gas condensing tankless water heater with a 120,000 BTU input and a stated flow rate of up to 6.6 GPM. It is described as an ultra-low-NOx model for homes with one or two baths. Unlike the Rheem options here, it is designed for outdoor placement, which may help preserve indoor space if the site and local conditions allow that setup.
The product information describes a wall-mounted design, integrated temperature controls, and diagnostic features intended to simplify troubleshooting. It also lists venting options of 3-inch PVC up to 70 feet or 4-inch PVC up to 100 feet. Since this is an outdoor model, check the manufacturer’s instructions and local requirements for placement and protection from the elements before installation.
Its stated flow rate is close to the 6.8 GPM natural-gas Rheem, but the figures are not directly comparable: the Rheem rate is specified at a 35°F rise, while the A. O. Smith listing says “up to” 6.6 GPM without stating the same test condition. This model could suit a natural-gas home with moderate demand that favors an outdoor unit, but a qualified installer should confirm capacity for your climate and household use.
Pros:
- Outdoor wall-mount design can free up indoor space
- Natural-gas fuel and ultra-low-NOx designation
- Integrated temperature controls and diagnostic features
- Two stated PVC venting configurations
Cons:
- Outdoor placement may not work for every site or climate
- Its listed flow rate is not given with the same temperature-rise condition as the Rheem models
Verdict: Consider this A. O. Smith if you want an outdoor natural-gas unit for a smaller home and have a suitable installation location; compare its output with a professional’s demand calculation before buying.
How to Choose a Low-NOx Tankless Water Heater
Confirm the Fuel Available at Your Home
Start by checking whether your home has natural gas or liquid propane. The two Rheem models in this guide use different fuels, and they are not interchangeable. The A. O. Smith option uses natural gas. Confirm the fuel connection and supply capacity with a qualified installer before selecting a unit.
Size the Heater for Peak Hot-Water Use
Think about how many showers, faucets, or appliances may need hot water at the same time. A heater’s GPM rating is useful, but it must be read alongside its temperature-rise condition. The two Rheem models state flow at a 35°F rise; the A. O. Smith listing gives an “up to” rate without the same condition. Ask an installer to estimate demand using your incoming-water temperature and the flow rates of your fixtures.
Choose Indoor or Outdoor Installation
The Rheem units are designed for indoor installation with direct venting, while the A. O. Smith is an outdoor model. Consider available wall space, vent routing, and the location of gas and water connections. Outdoor placement also depends on site conditions and applicable installation instructions, so do not choose based on indoor space alone.
Check Local Low-NOx and Building Requirements
Low-NOx requirements can depend on where you live, and a product’s emissions description does not replace local code approval. Confirm that the exact model meets the rules for your area. Check permit needs, venting rules, and installation clearances before ordering.
Compare Efficiency and Warranty Details
The Rheem listings state a 0.93 UEF and identify a 15-year heat-exchanger warranty and five-year parts warranty. The supplied A. O. Smith information does not provide those same figures, so compare the complete warranty documents rather than assuming the terms match. Efficiency figures are useful, but your actual energy use will also depend on hot-water demand and installation.
Plan for Professional Installation
Tankless gas heaters require the correct fuel supply, venting, water connections, and setup. Rheem recommends professional installation for both models. Even where a product description does not make the same recommendation, a qualified installer can confirm sizing, local code compliance, and the requirements of your chosen location.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does low-NOx mean for a water heater?
NOx refers to nitrogen oxide emissions. A low-NOx designation indicates that the product is designed to meet an emissions limit, but the exact requirement can vary by location. Verify local rules for the specific model before purchasing.
Can I use a propane water heater with a natural-gas connection?
No. The Rheem 9.5 GPM model listed here is for liquid propane, while the other two options use natural gas. Choose a unit that matches your home’s fuel supply and have the connection confirmed by an installer.
How much flow rate do I need?
That depends on how many fixtures you expect to use at once and how much the heater must raise the incoming water temperature. Use the stated GPM as a starting point, then have an installer calculate your home’s peak demand.
Is an indoor or outdoor tankless water heater better?
Neither is best for every home. An indoor model needs a suitable location and direct venting. An outdoor model can save indoor space, but it needs an appropriate exterior location and must be installed according to the manufacturer’s instructions and local code.
Are the flow rates in this guide directly comparable?
Not exactly. Both Rheem models state their GPM at a 35°F rise. The A. O. Smith listing gives a rate of up to 6.6 GPM without the same stated temperature-rise condition, so compare detailed specifications before deciding.
Do these tankless models provide unlimited hot water?
Tankless heaters warm water on demand, but their output is limited by the unit’s capacity, incoming-water temperature, and the number of fixtures in use. “Endless” or continuous hot water should not be taken to mean unlimited flow at every temperature.
Final Recommendation
For a natural-gas home needing an indoor unit, the Rheem RTGH 6.8 GPM is the straightforward moderate-capacity option. The Rheem RTGH 9.5 GPM is the better fit for a propane home with higher simultaneous demand. If you prefer an outdoor natural-gas unit for a one- or two-bath home, consider the A. O. Smith ProLine XE, while confirming its output and installation conditions with a qualified professional. The right choice is the one that matches your fuel, location, local low-NOx rules, and measured hot-water demand.