Choosing a shower curtain is about more than color: the right setup can make your bathroom easier to maintain, more private, and better suited to your style. These five options range from decorative swag sets with liners to simple fabric curtains and a detachable-liner design. Compare what comes in each set, how it fits your shower, and whether you need to buy hooks or a liner separately.
Table of Contents
Quick Comparison
| Product | Size | Standout feature | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Castle Selection Double Swag Ruffled Curtain Set | 70 x 72 inches | Swag valance, tie backs, liner, and roller rings | A dressed-up, coordinated look |
| Castle Selection Linen Double Swag Set | 70 x 72 inches | Polyester-linen fabric, liner, and sliding rings | A layered look in black |
| N&Y HOME Waffle Weave Curtain with Snap-in Liner | 71 x 72 inches | Removable liner and mesh upper panel | Easy liner removal and washing |
| Amazon Basics Water-Resistant Fabric Curtain | Standard size | Water-repellent fabric and weighted hem | A practical, simple setup |
| Martha Stewart Cotton Floral Shower Curtain | 72 x 72 inches | 100% cotton botanical print | Floral, farmhouse-inspired decor |
Our Picks: Best Selection Of Shower Curtains reviews
1. Castle Selection Double Swag Ruffled Set for a Dressy Bathroom
This Castle Selection set is made for a more decorative bathroom. Its 70-by-72-inch fabric curtain has a jacquard intersecting-leaves pattern, an attached ruffled valance, and a double-swag style. Two ruffled tie backs and adhesive hooks are included to complete the look.
The set also comes with a 70-by-72-inch frosted-clear PEVA liner and 12 metal roller rings with steel beads. That combination means you get the curtain, liner, and rings together rather than needing to piece together the basics. The decorative details do take up more visual space than a plain curtain, so consider whether the layered style suits your bathroom.
Pros:
- Includes fabric curtain, PEVA liner, and roller rings
- Attached valance and tie backs create a coordinated, layered look
- Jacquard leaf pattern adds texture without relying on a bold print
- Standard 70-by-72-inch dimensions fit many tubs and showers
Cons:
- The ruffles and swag style may feel too formal or ornate for a minimalist bathroom
- Check your shower dimensions before choosing a standard-size curtain
Verdict: Choose this set if you want a decorative curtain with a liner and rings included, and you like a traditional, ruffled look.
2. Castle Selection Linen Double Swag Set in Black
This black Castle Selection set pairs a double-swag shape with pleated edges and an attached ruffled valance. Its fabric is listed as 95% polyester and 5% linen, offering a linen-style look with a blend rather than an all-linen construction. The curtain measures 70 by 72 inches.
The set includes two ruffled tie backs, two adhesive wall-mounting hooks, 12 metal sliding rings, and a clear PEVA liner. That makes it a coordinated option if you want the layered design and the main hanging pieces in one package. The product information supplied for this article lists it as unavailable, so check the listing before planning around it.
Pros:
- Includes a clear PEVA liner and 12 metal sliding rings
- Black color and ruffled details create a dramatic, tailored look
- Polyester-linen blend offers a linen-inspired appearance
- Tie backs and adhesive hooks are included
Cons:
- The supplied product information lists this item as unavailable; availability may change
- The black, ruffled style may not suit bright or understated bathroom decor
Verdict: Consider this set if you want a black swag curtain with a liner and rings, but confirm it is available before making plans to buy.
3. N&Y HOME Waffle Weave Curtain with a Detachable Liner
This 71-by-72-inch white curtain uses a waffle weave for a simple, hotel-inspired look. Its key feature is a same-color liner that snaps on and off, so you can remove the liner for cleaning or replacement without taking down the whole curtain. The set also includes 12 white metal hooks.
A mesh upper panel lets light and air pass through while still providing a degree of separation from the rest of the bathroom. Because the panel is see-through, it is worth considering how much privacy you want. The curtain and liner are described as water-repellent and quick-drying, and the liner has magnets at the two bottom corners to help hold it in place.
Pros:
- Snap-on liner can be removed separately for cleaning or replacement
- Includes 12 metal hooks for installation
- Mesh upper panel allows light and air circulation
- Water-repellent materials are designed to dry quickly
Cons:
- The sheer upper panel may not suit bathrooms where full visual privacy is a priority
- White fabric may need more frequent cleaning to keep it looking fresh
Verdict: Pick this set if a removable liner and a light, waffle-weave look matter more to you than a fully opaque curtain.
4. Amazon Basics Water-Resistant Curtain with a Weighted Hem
This fabric curtain has a blue-and-white ombre chevron pattern, giving it a more modern look than a plain solid color. Its water-repellent fabric is designed to help keep water inside the tub, while the weighted hem adds stability. Rust-resistant metal grommets and 12 white plastic hooks are included.
The product information describes the curtain as usable with or without a liner. A separate liner may still be useful if you want an additional barrier or prefer to keep the fabric curtain farther from direct spray. Unlike the Castle Selection sets, this option does not include a separate liner or decorative tie backs.
Pros:
- Water-repellent fabric helps contain splashes
- Weighted hem is designed to help the curtain stay in place
- Includes rust-resistant metal grommets and 12 plastic hooks
- Machine-washable fabric is designed for regular use
Cons:
- A separate liner is not listed as included
- The chevron pattern may not fit every bathroom style
Verdict: This is a practical choice if you want a patterned, water-repellent fabric curtain with hooks included and do not need a bundled liner.
5. Martha Stewart Cotton Floral Curtain for a Botanical Accent
This 72-by-72-inch curtain is made from 100% cotton and features a botanical floral print on a white background. The pattern brings color and a garden-inspired accent to a bathroom without the ruffles or layered valance of the Castle Selection options.
It has buttonholes for shower hooks, but hooks are not included. A separate liner is recommended, so factor that into your setup. The care instructions call for machine washing separately in cold water on a gentle cycle and tumble drying on low heat.
Pros:
- 100% cotton construction with a botanical floral print
- White background can brighten a bathroom’s color scheme
- Standard 72-by-72-inch dimensions
- Care instructions allow machine washing
Cons:
- Shower hooks and a liner are not included
- Requires separate purchases to complete the setup
Verdict: Choose this curtain if you want a cotton floral design and are comfortable buying hooks and a liner separately.
How to Choose a Shower Curtain
Measure your shower before you order
Measure the width of your shower rod and the distance from the rod to the tub or floor. The options here are around 70 to 72 inches wide and 72 inches long, but even a small difference can affect how much coverage you get. A curtain that is too short may leave gaps, while extra length can bunch near the floor or tub edge.
Decide whether you need a liner
Some sets include a liner, while others do not. The Castle Selection options and N&Y HOME set include one, while the Amazon Basics and Martha Stewart curtains do not list a liner in the package. A liner can act as a separate barrier behind a fabric curtain. If you choose a curtain without one, decide whether to add a liner before installing it.
Check what comes in the package
Hooks and rings are not interchangeable across every listing, so check the included hardware. The Castle Selection sets include metal rings, and the N&Y HOME set includes metal hooks. Amazon Basics includes plastic hooks, while the Martha Stewart curtain has buttonholes but does not include hooks. Knowing this ahead of time helps you avoid a second trip for basic setup items.
Match the fabric and pattern to your routine
Fabric affects both the look and the care needs of a curtain. The Martha Stewart option is cotton and has specific machine-washing instructions. The Amazon Basics curtain is described as water-repellent and machine washable, while the N&Y HOME set is also described as water-repellent and quick-drying. For a more decorative room, consider the ruffles and valance on the Castle Selection sets; for a simpler look, consider the waffle weave or floral print.
Think about privacy and light
The N&Y HOME curtain includes a mesh upper panel that lets light and air through, but it is also see-through. That may suit a bathroom where brightness matters, but it may not be the best match if you want full visual coverage. More opaque fabric styles may be a better fit when privacy is your first concern.
Consider how much decor you want
A shower curtain can be a focal point or a quiet backdrop. Double-swag curtains with ruffles make a stronger decorative statement and include more pieces to coordinate. A simple water-repellent curtain is easier to pair with other bathroom colors, while a floral or chevron print adds pattern without a layered valance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do all of these shower curtains include a liner?
No. The Castle Selection sets and N&Y HOME set list a liner as included. The Amazon Basics and Martha Stewart curtains do not list one in the supplied product details. The Martha Stewart description recommends using a liner.
Which option has a removable liner?
The N&Y HOME waffle-weave set has a snap-on liner that can be detached for cleaning or replacement. The other included liners are not described as snap-on or detachable.
Are shower hooks included with every curtain?
No. N&Y HOME includes 12 metal hooks, and Amazon Basics includes 12 plastic hooks. The Castle Selection sets include metal roller rings. The Martha Stewart curtain has buttonholes, but hooks are not included.
Can I machine-wash these curtains?
The Amazon Basics curtain is described as machine washable. The N&Y HOME set can be machine or hand washed. Martha Stewart specifies washing separately in cold water on a gentle cycle and tumble drying on low. Check the product listing for care instructions for the Castle Selection curtains before washing.
Which curtain is best for a simple, modern look?
The Amazon Basics curtain has a blue-and-white chevron pattern without a ruffled valance. The N&Y HOME option has a white waffle weave with a mesh upper panel. Your choice depends on whether you prefer a bolder pattern or a more understated texture.
What should I know about the black Castle Selection set?
The supplied product information lists the black Castle Selection set as unavailable. Its listing may change, so confirm availability before choosing it. The description lists a 70-by-72-inch curtain, a liner, sliding rings, tie backs, and adhesive hooks.
Final Recommendation
For a coordinated, decorative set with a liner and hanging hardware, the Castle Selection leaf-pattern curtain is a strong fit if you like its ruffled style. For a practical everyday option, the Amazon Basics curtain includes hooks and has a weighted hem, but you may want to add a liner. Choose N&Y HOME if a detachable liner is your top priority, or Martha Stewart if you want a cotton floral curtain and do not mind buying the hooks and liner separately.
