If you’ve ever stepped into the shower only to find water still pouring from the tub spout—or worse, no water coming from the showerhead at all—your push button shower diverter may be to blame. This small but crucial component directs water flow between your bathtub faucet and showerhead with a simple press. When it’s working, you probably don’t think twice. But when it fails, it can disrupt your entire bathing routine.
A push button shower diverter not working is a common problem in many homes, especially in areas with hard water or aging plumbing fixtures. Fortunately, understanding what causes the issue and how to fix it can save you time, frustration, and even the cost of a plumber.
In this guide, we’ll explore the most frequent signs of diverter failure, the reasons behind it, and step-by-step DIY solutions to get your shower back in working order. Whether you’re a seasoned DIYer or a curious homeowner, you’ll find practical tips and clear explanations to tackle the issue with confidence.
Table of Contents
2. What Is a Push Button Shower Diverter?
A push button shower diverter is a simple but essential plumbing device that controls the flow of water between your bathtub faucet and your showerhead. Instead of using a traditional lever or pull-up spout, this modern design allows you to switch between tub and shower functions by pressing a button—usually located on the top or side of the tub spout or integrated into the shower panel.
When you press the button, it activates an internal mechanism that diverts water from the tub spout up to the showerhead. Pressing it again either resets the flow to the tub or automatically does so when you turn off the water, depending on the design. The push button style is sleek, space-saving, and increasingly popular in modern bathrooms for its minimalist look and ease of use.
Push button diverters come in different configurations:
-
Built-in diverters (part of a thermostatic valve or shower system)
-
Spout-mounted diverters (common in bathtub/shower combos)
Although they enhance convenience and aesthetics, push button diverters are just as susceptible to wear, mineral buildup, and mechanical failure as other types. Understanding how they work helps you better diagnose problems when they arise—especially if your push button shower diverter is not working properly.
3. Signs Your Push Button Shower Diverter Is Not Working
When your push button shower diverter isn’t working, the symptoms are usually easy to spot—but it’s important to identify them correctly to avoid unnecessary plumbing work or replacement parts. Here are the most common signs that your diverter may be malfunctioning:
3.1 Water Flows from Both the Showerhead and Tub Spout
One of the clearest signs of a faulty diverter is when water continues to pour from the tub spout even after you’ve activated the shower. This split water flow usually indicates that the diverter valve isn’t fully sealing or redirecting the water upward.
3.2 No Water Comes Out of the Showerhead
If you press the button and nothing happens—no water comes out of the showerhead—it could mean the internal diverter mechanism is stuck, broken, or clogged with debris. This issue might also be caused by a blocked showerhead, but the diverter is often the main culprit.
3.3 The Button Is Stuck or Doesn’t Pop Out
A button that doesn’t move when pressed or doesn’t reset properly after use could signal a mechanical problem. Mineral buildup or a worn spring inside the diverter can prevent smooth operation, leaving the button jammed or unresponsive.
3.4 Reduced Water Pressure in the Shower
If your showerhead is producing weak or inconsistent water pressure, the diverter may be partially blocked or failing to open fully. This can also be a sign of internal leaks in the diverter assembly.
3.5 The Diverter Makes Strange Noises
Clicking, grinding, or hissing sounds when using the diverter can suggest internal wear or air being pulled into the system due to poor sealing. While this isn’t always a critical issue, it’s often a warning sign of a developing problem.
4. Common Causes of a Malfunctioning Push Button Diverter
When your push button shower diverter stops working, it’s usually due to wear, debris, or a mechanical issue inside the fixture. Let’s break down the most common causes so you can better diagnose and fix the problem.
4.1 Mineral Buildup or Debris
One of the most frequent culprits is mineral buildup—especially in areas with hard water. Over time, calcium and lime deposits can collect inside the diverter mechanism, restricting movement or blocking water flow. You may also find bits of rust or debris from old pipes jamming the mechanism.
Signs:
-
Button becomes hard to press or stuck
-
Inconsistent or weak water flow
-
Diverter doesn’t fully switch between tub and shower
4.2 Worn Out Internal Seals or O-Rings
Inside most push button diverters are rubber washers and O-rings that help form a tight seal to redirect water. With age and frequent use, these rubber components can crack, dry out, or wear thin, leading to leaks or weak redirection.
Signs:
-
Water leaks from both outlets
-
Button feels loose or spongy
-
Reduced shower pressure
4.3 Broken or Jammed Button Mechanism
The internal parts of the push button diverter, including the spring or plunger, can wear out or break over time. A jammed or broken spring means the button won’t pop in or out properly, making it difficult or impossible to change water flow direction.
Signs:
-
Button won’t stay pressed or won’t press at all
-
Clicking sound with no water redirection
-
Button feels stuck or detached internally
4.4 Installation Errors or Aging Fixtures
Sometimes, the issue lies not in wear and tear, but in a poor installation. If the diverter was installed incorrectly, it might never have worked as it should. Alternatively, if your plumbing is old, the diverter might simply be at the end of its life.
Signs:
-
Diverter has always been unreliable
-
Button alignment seems off
-
Inconsistent or sudden loss of function
5. DIY Troubleshooting and Fixes
Fixing a push button shower diverter may seem intimidating, but many common issues can be resolved with simple tools and a little patience. Here are some DIY fixes to get your shower working again without calling a plumber.
5.1 Cleaning Mineral Deposits
If your diverter is stuck or not functioning properly due to mineral buildup, cleaning it can often restore functionality.
What You’ll Need:
-
White vinegar
-
Adjustable wrench
-
Old toothbrush or soft brush
-
Soft cloth or towel
Steps:
-
Turn off the water supply.
-
Remove the tub spout or diverter unit (usually unscrews counterclockwise; check for a hidden set screw).
-
Soak the diverter in vinegar for 30–60 minutes to dissolve mineral deposits.
-
Scrub gently with a toothbrush to remove buildup.
-
Rinse and dry before reinstalling.
This simple method often fixes a stuck or partially blocked diverter.
5.2 Lubricating or Replacing the Button Mechanism
If the push button feels stiff or doesn’t engage properly, a little lubrication can help. If the spring or internal button is broken, replacement may be needed.
Steps:
-
Disassemble the diverter unit carefully.
-
Apply plumber’s grease to moving parts, especially the spring and plunger.
-
If the spring is broken, replace it (you may need a diverter repair kit).
-
Reassemble and test the button for smooth operation.
5.3 Replacing Seals and O-Rings
Worn-out rubber seals are a common cause of leaks and pressure issues.
What You’ll Need:
-
Replacement seals or O-rings (check manufacturer specs)
-
Flathead screwdriver or pick tool
-
Plumber’s grease
Steps:
-
Disassemble the diverter and locate the seals and O-rings.
-
Remove and inspect them for cracks or wear.
-
Replace with new parts and lubricate with plumber’s grease.
-
Reassemble and test to see if water flow is restored.
5.4 Full Diverter Replacement (If Necessary)
If all else fails and the diverter is old or heavily damaged, a full replacement might be the best solution.
Steps:
-
Purchase a compatible diverter unit (match model and size).
-
Shut off the water and remove the old diverter.
-
Install the new diverter, following the instructions.
-
Seal any threaded joints with plumber’s tape to prevent leaks.
-
Turn water back on and test thoroughly.
Replacement diverters are usually affordable and widely available at hardware stores or online.
6. When to Call a Plumber
While many push button shower diverter issues can be solved with basic tools and some DIY effort, there are times when it’s safer, faster, and ultimately more cost-effective to leave the job to a professional plumber.
Here’s how to know when it’s time to call in expert help:
6.1 DIY Fixes Aren’t Working
If you’ve tried cleaning, lubricating, or even replacing parts but your diverter still doesn’t function properly, there may be a deeper issue within the plumbing system—such as internal pipe blockages, faulty connections, or corrosion that can’t be seen without removing the wall panel or pipes.
6.2 The Diverter Is Built Into the Wall
Some push button diverters are integrated into the wall or connected directly to a thermostatic valve system. In these cases, accessing the diverter can involve removing tile or cutting into drywall, which is risky without the right tools or experience.
Why it matters:
Incorrect removal or installation could lead to leaks inside the wall, causing mold or water damage.
6.3 Water Pressure Problems Throughout the Bathroom
If the diverter issue is accompanied by low pressure in other fixtures, or affects both hot and cold water, the root problem may lie in your home’s plumbing system rather than the diverter itself.
A plumber can perform a full diagnostic to pinpoint pressure-related problems and determine if they stem from clogged lines, corroded pipes, or a failing pressure regulator.
6.4 Signs of Leaks Behind the Wall
Water stains, peeling paint, musty odors, or persistent dampness around your shower area could indicate that water is leaking behind the wall due to a faulty or poorly installed diverter. This is a serious issue that requires immediate professional attention.
6.5 You Want to Upgrade the Whole System
If your diverter is failing and your shower fixtures are outdated, it may be a good opportunity to upgrade your entire setup. A plumber can help recommend and install more reliable diverter valves, multi-function shower systems, or water-efficient options that improve both performance and appearance.
Cost Consideration: DIY vs. Professional Repair
-
DIY fixes (cleaning, replacing seals): $0–$20
-
Diverter replacement parts: $20–$60
-
Professional plumber visit: $100–$300 depending on the complexity
In many cases, a plumber can complete the job more efficiently and ensure it’s up to code—especially if the issue is not just the diverter, but a symptom of something larger.
7. Preventive Tips to Avoid Future Issues
Taking a few simple steps can extend the life of your push button shower diverter and prevent unexpected malfunctions. Proper maintenance doesn’t just save time and money—it helps your bathroom plumbing run smoothly for years to come.
7.1 Regularly Clean the Diverter
Mineral deposits from hard water are a top cause of diverter failure. Every few months, clean the diverter with white vinegar to dissolve buildup:
-
Remove the spout or diverter (if accessible).
-
Soak it in vinegar for 30 minutes.
-
Rinse and scrub with a soft brush.
This keeps the internal parts moving freely and prevents blockage.
7.2 Operate the Button Gently
Press the button firmly but gently—no need to jam it. Forcing the diverter can damage internal springs or seals over time. Make sure others in the household (especially children) know how to use it properly too.
7.3 Use a Water Softener (If Applicable)
If your home has hard water, consider installing a whole-house water softener or a shower-specific filter. These systems reduce calcium and magnesium in the water, minimizing the buildup that damages fixtures like diverters, faucets, and showerheads.
7.4 Check for Leaks Early
Periodically inspect your tub spout and showerhead for:
-
Drips when the water is off
-
Water flowing from both outlets at once
-
Low water pressure
These early warning signs often indicate diverter wear and give you a chance to fix the issue before it worsens.
7.5 Schedule Annual Plumbing Maintenance
Having a plumber inspect your bathroom plumbing once a year can help catch small problems before they lead to bigger repairs. They can also recommend upgrades if your diverter or fixtures are outdated.
7.6 Keep an Eye on Showerhead Clogs
A clogged showerhead puts pressure on the diverter system. Clean it regularly to ensure smooth water flow, which helps reduce stress on the diverter mechanism.
By incorporating these habits into your bathroom maintenance routine, you’ll significantly lower the risk of your push button shower diverter not working in the future.
8. Conclusion
A push button shower diverter not working can be a frustrating inconvenience, but the good news is that most issues are easy to identify and fix. Whether it’s a stuck button, a weak water flow, or water coming from both outlets, there’s usually a straightforward cause—like mineral buildup, worn seals, or a jammed mechanism.
With basic tools and a little DIY effort, many homeowners can clean or replace faulty components without calling a plumber. But if your diverter is built into the wall, leaking behind the scenes, or causing water pressure problems throughout the bathroom, don’t hesitate to contact a professional.
To prevent future issues, stay on top of maintenance—clean the diverter regularly, handle the button gently, and consider using a water softener if you live in a hard water area.
By following the steps in this guide, you’ll not only fix your diverter but also keep your bathroom running smoothly and efficiently for years to come.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. What causes a push button shower diverter to stop working?
Common causes include mineral buildup from hard water, worn-out seals or O-rings, a broken or jammed button mechanism, and sometimes improper installation or aging fixtures.
2. How can I fix a stuck push button shower diverter?
You can try cleaning it by soaking the diverter in white vinegar to dissolve mineral deposits, lubricating the moving parts with plumber’s grease, or replacing worn springs or seals. If these don’t work, a full replacement may be needed.
3. Why does water come from both the tub spout and the showerhead at the same time?
This usually happens when the diverter valve isn’t sealing properly, often due to worn-out internal seals or mineral deposits preventing a full switch between tub and shower flow.
4. Can I replace a push button shower diverter myself?
Yes, if you’re comfortable with basic plumbing tasks, you can replace a spout-mounted diverter by purchasing a compatible unit and following instructions. However, if the diverter is built into the wall or you’re unsure, it’s best to call a professional.
5. How often should I clean my shower diverter?
It’s a good idea to clean your diverter every few months, especially if you have hard water. Regular cleaning helps prevent mineral buildup that can cause the diverter to stick or malfunction.
6. What tools do I need to fix or replace a push button diverter?
Typically, you’ll need an adjustable wrench, white vinegar (for cleaning), plumber’s grease, replacement O-rings or seals (if necessary), a screwdriver or pick tool, and possibly a new diverter unit for replacement.
7. When should I call a plumber for my diverter problem?
Call a plumber if DIY fixes don’t work, if the diverter is built into the wall, if you notice leaks behind the wall, or if there are water pressure problems affecting other fixtures in your home.
8. Does hard water affect the performance of push button shower diverters?
Yes, hard water causes mineral deposits to build up inside the diverter mechanism, which can cause sticking, leaks, and reduced water flow. Installing a water softener can help reduce these problems.
